Key takeaways
View moreTarget appears moderately undervalued based on its current valuation multiples being significantly below industry averages, despite maintaining above-average profitability metrics. The company's investments in digital channels and supply chain capabilities, along with its strong brand and loyal customer base, provide potential for future growth that may not be fully reflected in the current stock price.
- Target's financial performance has been declining in recent quarters, with revenue growth slowing and profitability decreasing. This decline is likely due to a combination of factors, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, and changing consumer preferences.
- Despite these challenges, Target has a strong liquidity position and a healthy long-term solvency profile. However, the company's operational efficiency is declining, and its cash flow from operations has been decreasing, raising concerns about its future prospects.
- Target's stock price has underperformed its peers and the broader consumer discretionary sector over the past three years. This underperformance is likely due to the company's struggles to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment, its ongoing efforts to adapt to changing consumer preferences, and its focus on digital transformation.
- Target's valuation is currently below its industry average, suggesting that investors are discounting the company's future growth prospects. However, the company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth, which could lead to an increase in its valuation.
- Target faces a number of risks, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, changing consumer preferences, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively. The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape will be critical to its future success.
Evaluation summary
Add to research
-
Company Overview:
- Target Corp. (TGT) is a general merchandise retailer operating in the United States, Canada, and Mexico. The company's core business model revolves around offering a wide range of products across various categories, including Apparel & Accessories, Beauty & Household Essentials, Food & Beverage, Hardlines, and Home Furnishings & Decor. Target's revenue is generated through its physical stores and digital channels, with a focus on providing a seamless customer experience across both platforms. The company competes with a wide range of retailers, including department stores, off-price retailers, wholesale clubs, and direct-to-consumer brands.
- Target's revenue is primarily driven by its physical stores, which account for the majority of its sales. However, the company has been investing heavily in its digital channels, which have been growing at a faster pace than its physical stores. In fiscal 2023, Target's total revenue declined by 1.6%, driven by a 3.7% decrease in comparable sales.
- For comparative analysis, Target is benchmarked against the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY) and its industry peers, Walmart, Inc. (WMT) and Costco Wholesale Corp. (COST).
-
Financial Performance:
- Target's financial performance has been declining in recent quarters. Total revenue declined by 3.1% in Q1 2024, with comparable sales down 3.7%. This decline was driven by softness in the Home and Hardlines categories. However, the company saw continued strength in Beauty and improvement in Apparel, as well as growth in digital sales driven by same-day services like Drive Up.
- Despite the decline in revenue, Target's profitability has remained relatively stable. Earnings per share (EPS) of $2.03 in Q1 2024, up 33% compared to Q1 2019 but below the company's long-term expectations. This increase in EPS was driven by cost savings, which improved gross margins. However, SG&A rate increased due to higher compensation, benefits, and marketing costs.
- Target's profitability ratios have been declining in recent quarters. The company's Gross Profit Margin has improved to 26.5% in fiscal 2023 due to lower freight and fulfillment costs, partially offset by higher inventory shrink. However, the company's Net Profit Margin has declined to 3.33% in Q1 2024, indicating a decrease in profitability.
- Target's Return on Assets (ROA) has declined to 7.62% in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of -0.19%. The company's Return on Equity (ROE) has also declined to 32.37% in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of -60.17%. The company's Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) has declined to 13.94% in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of -1.18%. These declining profitability ratios suggest that Target is facing challenges in generating returns on its assets and equity.
- Recent news reports have highlighted the impact of inflation and consumer uncertainty on Target's financial performance. The company has been facing pressure on discretionary spending, which has impacted sales in certain categories. However, Target has also been investing in price investment initiatives and expanding its digital marketplace, which could help to drive future growth.
-
Operational Efficiency:
- Target's working capital has been declining in recent quarters, indicating potential inefficiencies in its working capital management. The company's Working Capital has decreased to -1238.0 in Q1 2024, indicating a decline in its ability to manage its current assets and liabilities effectively.
- Target's cash flow from operations has been declining in recent quarters, which is a concern for the company's future prospects. The company's Net Operating Cash Flow has decreased to 739.0 in Q1 2024, indicating a decline in its ability to generate cash from its core operations.
- Target's free cash flow has been declining in recent quarters, which could be a sign of declining cash flow quality. The company's Free Cash Flow to Equity has decreased to 84.0 in Q1 2024, indicating a decline in its ability to generate cash flow after accounting for capital expenditures.
- Target's capital expenditures have been decreasing in recent quarters, which could be a sign of a slowdown in growth or a shift in investment strategy. The company's Total Capital Expenditure has decreased to 655.0 in Q1 2024, indicating a decline in its investment in its physical assets.
- Target has been returning cash to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. The company's Cash Dividends Paid have remained relatively stable at 516.0 in Q1 2024. However, the company's Change in Capital Stock has been negative in recent quarters, indicating a reduction in its share count.
- Target's liquidity ratios have been declining in recent quarters, indicating a decline in its ability to meet its short-term obligations. The company's Current Ratio has decreased to 0.94 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 1.61. The company's Quick Ratio has decreased to 0.25 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 0.84.
- Target's debt-to-equity and leverage ratios have been declining in recent quarters, indicating a decrease in financial leverage. The company's Total Debt to Total Equity Ratio has decreased to 159.87 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 306.45. The company's Debt / EBITDA has decreased to 1.79 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 9.86.
-
Growth Opportunities:
- Target has been investing in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities, which could help to drive future growth. The company has expanded its supply chain capacity and digital fulfillment capabilities, including adding new distribution facilities. It has also rolled out new services like Drive Up with Starbucks and Returns with Drive Up.
- Target has been investing in new owned brands, designer collaborations, and store remodels/expansions. The company has been exploring opportunities to expand the reach of its owned brands, such as the launch of Cat & Jack in Canada through a partnership with Hudson's Bay.
- Target has been expanding its geographic reach, with plans to open new stores in Canada and Mexico. The company has also been investing in its digital channels, which could help to drive growth in new markets.
- Target's current strategic focus areas include driving top-line growth, maintaining profitability through operational efficiency and cost management, and delivering value and convenience to customers. The company is focused on operational excellence, agility, and delivering value and convenience to customers, as evidenced by its price investment initiatives and continued investment in the Target Circle loyalty program and digital marketplace.
- Target has made progress on its previously announced initiatives, such as the relaunch of the Target Circle loyalty program and the expansion of the Target Plus digital marketplace. The company has also been investing in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities, which could help to drive future growth.
- Target's capital allocation strategies are aligned with its company goals of driving top-line growth, maintaining profitability, and returning cash to shareholders. The company has maintained a disciplined capital allocation approach, investing in growth initiatives while returning cash to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases.
-
Recent Developments and Market Sentiment:
- Recent news reports have highlighted the impact of inflation and consumer uncertainty on Target's financial performance. The company has been facing pressure on discretionary spending, which has impacted sales in certain categories. However, Target has also been investing in price investment initiatives and expanding its digital marketplace, which could help to drive future growth.
- The overall market sentiment towards Target is cautious, with analysts expressing concerns about the company's ability to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment. However, some analysts remain optimistic about Target's long-term growth prospects, citing the company's strong brand, loyal customer base, and investments in its digital channels.
- Major news items that have impacted Target's performance include the company's announcement of price cuts on 1,500 frequently shopped items, its continued investment in the relaunch of the Target Circle loyalty program and expansion of the Target Plus digital marketplace, and its exploration of opportunities to expand the reach of its owned brands.
-
Risks and Threats:
- Target faces a number of risks, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, changing consumer preferences, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively. The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape will be critical to its future success.
- The retail industry continues to see a shift towards digital channels and multiple fulfillment options for consumers. Changing consumer preferences and spending patterns can impact Target's ability to make trend-right merchandising decisions. Macroeconomic conditions, inflation, interest rates, and other external factors can affect consumer confidence and spending.
- Target faces competition from a wide range of retailers, including department stores, off-price retailers, wholesale clubs, and direct-to-consumer brands. The company will need to continue to differentiate its customer experience and offer competitive pricing in order to maintain its market share.
- Target faces regulatory risks, including labor and employment matters. The company has been facing scrutiny from regulators over its labor practices, and it could face additional legal challenges in the future.
- Recent news reports have highlighted the impact of inflation and consumer uncertainty on Target's financial performance. The company has been facing pressure on discretionary spending, which has impacted sales in certain categories.
-
Valuation Analysis:
- Target's valuation metrics have been declining in recent quarters, indicating a decline in investor confidence. The company's Enterprise Value To EBITDA has decreased to 9.18 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 22.51. The company's Enterprise Value To Sales has decreased to 0.83 in Q1 2024, which is below the industry average of 1.62.
- Target's valuation is currently below its industry average, suggesting that investors are discounting the company's future growth prospects. However, the company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth, which could lead to an increase in its valuation.
- Potential catalysts that could impact Target's valuation include the company's continued investment in its digital channels, its expansion into new markets, and its ability to manage costs effectively.
-
Price Performance:
- Target's stock price has underperformed its peers and the broader consumer discretionary sector over the past three years. The company's stock price has declined by 13.02% over the past three years, compared to a 6.97% increase in the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY).
- Target's stock price has been more volatile than its peers and the broader consumer discretionary sector. The company's stock price has experienced a maximum drawdown of 58.87% over the past three years, compared to a 39.67% maximum drawdown in the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY).
- Recent price movements in Target's stock have been influenced by the company's financial performance, its investments in its digital channels, and the overall market sentiment.
-
Future Outlook:
- Target's management has expressed confidence in the company's long-term vision and ability to deliver profitable growth, despite the near-term challenges. The company expects a comparable sales increase of 0% to 2% in Q2 and for the full year, with EPS guidance of $1.95 to $2.35 in Q2 and $8.60 to $9.60 for the full year.
- Analyst estimates for Target's future performance are mixed. Some analysts remain optimistic about the company's long-term growth prospects, citing the company's strong brand, loyal customer base, and investments in its digital channels. However, other analysts are more cautious, citing the company's struggles to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment.
- Recent news and developments are expected to influence Target's future performance. The company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth. However, the company will need to continue to innovate and adapt to the changing retail landscape in order to maintain its competitive position.
-
Summary:
- Target Corp. (TGT) is a general merchandise retailer with a strong brand and a loyal customer base. However, the company faces a number of challenges, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, changing consumer preferences, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively.
- Target's financial performance has been declining in recent quarters, with revenue growth slowing and profitability decreasing. The company's operational efficiency is declining, and its cash flow from operations has been decreasing, raising concerns about its future prospects.
- Target's stock price has underperformed its peers and the broader consumer discretionary sector over the past three years. This underperformance is likely due to the company's struggles to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment, its ongoing efforts to adapt to changing consumer preferences, and its focus on digital transformation.
- Target's valuation is currently below its industry average, suggesting that investors are discounting the company's future growth prospects. However, the company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth, which could lead to an increase in its valuation.
- Target's future outlook is uncertain, as it faces a number of challenges. The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape will be critical to its future success. Investors should carefully consider these challenges before making an investment decision.
- Strengths:
- Strong brand and loyal customer base
- Investments in supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities
- Disciplined capital allocation approach
- Weaknesses:
- Declining financial performance
- Declining operational efficiency
- Struggles to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment
- Opportunities:
- Continued investment in digital channels
- Expansion into new markets
- Ability to manage costs effectively
- Threats:
- Macroeconomic environment
- Increased competition
- Changing consumer preferences
- Regulatory risks
- Target's overall financial health is currently under pressure, with declining profitability and cash flow. The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape and manage costs effectively will be critical to its future success. Investors should carefully monitor the company's financial performance and its progress on its strategic initiatives.
Price history
Add to research
Fundamentals
Add to research
Insights
- Target's revenue growth has been declining, indicating a potential slowdown in sales.
- The company's profitability has been declining, as evidenced by the decrease in net income and the declining profitability ratios.
- The company's liquidity position appears to be strong, but the increasing short-term debt could be a concern if it is not managed effectively.
- The company's long-term solvency appears to be healthy, but the increasing short-term debt could be a concern if it is not managed effectively.
- The company's operational efficiency is declining, indicating a decline in efficiency.
- The company's cash flow from operations has been declining, which is a concern for the company's future prospects.
- The company faces a number of risks, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, changing consumer preferences, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively.
- The company's future outlook is uncertain, as it faces a number of challenges, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, and changing consumer preferences.
- The company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth.
- The company will need to continue to innovate and improve efficiency in order to maintain its competitive position.
Analysis
-
Revenue - The company's revenue growth has been declining, indicating a potential slowdown in sales. - This decline is likely due to a combination of factors, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, and changing consumer preferences. - The company has been investing in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities, which could help to drive future revenue growth. - However, the company will need to continue to innovate and adapt to the changing retail landscape in order to maintain its competitive position.
-
Profitability
- The company's profitability has been declining, as evidenced by the decrease in net income and the declining profitability ratios.
- This decline is likely due to a combination of factors, including the increasing operating expenses and the slowing revenue growth.
- The company has been able to control costs, as evidenced by the increase in gross margin.
- However, the company will need to find ways to control operating expenses and improve efficiency in order to improve profitability.
-
Liquidity
- The company's liquidity position appears to be strong, as evidenced by the increasing cash and short-term investments.
- However, the increasing short-term debt could be a concern if it is not managed effectively.
- The company's Current Ratio and Quick Ratio are both less than 1, indicating that the company may have difficulty meeting its short-term obligations.
- The company's Current Ratio and Quick Ratio are both significantly less than the Industry Average, indicating that the company is less liquid than its peers.
-
Solvency
- The company's long-term solvency appears to be healthy, as evidenced by the decreasing long-term debt and the positive free cash flow.
- However, the increasing short-term debt could be a concern if it is not managed effectively.
- The company's Total Debt to Total Equity Ratio and Debt / EBITDA are both decreasing, indicating a decrease in financial leverage.
- The company's Total Debt to Total Equity Ratio and Debt / EBITDA are both significantly less than the Industry Average, indicating that the company is less leveraged than its peers.
-
Operational Efficiency
- The company's operational efficiency is declining, as evidenced by the decreasing Return on Average Assets, Return on Average Total Equity, Return on Average Total Capital, and Return On Average Invested Capital.
- This decline is likely due to a combination of factors, including the increasing operating expenses and the slowing revenue growth.
- The company will need to find ways to improve efficiency in order to maintain its competitive position.
-
Cash Flow Analysis
- The company's cash flow from operations has been declining, which is a concern for the company's future prospects.
- The company's free cash flow has been declining, which could be a sign of declining cash flow quality.
- The company's capital expenditures have been decreasing, which could be a sign of a slowdown in growth or a shift in investment strategy.
- The company's cash flow / total debt ratio is decreasing, indicating a decline in the company's ability to generate cash flow to cover its debt obligations.
-
Risk Factors
- The company faces a number of risks, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, changing consumer preferences, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively.
- The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape will be critical to its future success.
- The company's increasing short-term debt could be a concern if it is not managed effectively.
-
Future Outlook
- The company's future outlook is uncertain, as it faces a number of challenges, including the macroeconomic environment, increased competition, and changing consumer preferences.
- The company's ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape will be critical to its future success.
- The company's investments in its supply chain and digital fulfillment capabilities could help to drive future growth.
- The company will need to continue to innovate and improve efficiency in order to maintain its competitive position.
-
Financial statements
Add to research
Loading...
Public filings
Add to research
- Target continues to focus on differentiating its customer experience through a combination of merchandise assortment, value, convenience, and loyalty programs. However, the company faces risks from changing consumer preferences, industry competition, and its ability to manage inventory and costs effectively.
- The shift towards digital channels and fulfillment options remains a key trend, requiring Target to invest in its supply chain, technology, and omnichannel capabilities. Successful execution of these initiatives will be critical to driving future growth and profitability.
- Macroeconomic conditions, inflation, and regulatory/legal risks pose ongoing challenges that could impact Target's financial performance and operations. The company will need to closely monitor these external factors and adapt its strategies accordingly.
- Target's strong cash flow generation and disciplined capital allocation approach have enabled it to invest in growth initiatives while returning capital to shareholders. Maintaining this balanced approach will be important for sustaining the company's competitive position.
Core Business and Operations:
- Target is a general merchandise retailer selling products to customers through its stores and digital channels
- The company operates as a single segment focused on enabling customers to purchase products seamlessly in stores or online
- Key product categories include Apparel & Accessories, Beauty & Household Essentials, Food & Beverage, Hardlines, and Home Furnishings & Decor
- Target competes with traditional and online retailers, including department stores, off-price retailers, wholesale clubs, and direct-to-consumer brands
- The company has a network of distribution centers and supply chain facilities to support its store and digital operations
Industry and Market Trends:
- The retail industry continues to see a shift towards digital channels and multiple fulfillment options for consumers
- Changing consumer preferences and spending patterns can impact Target's ability to make trend-right merchandising decisions
- Macroeconomic conditions, inflation, interest rates, and other external factors can affect consumer confidence and spending
Recent Events:
- Expanded supply chain capacity and digital fulfillment capabilities, including adding new distribution facilities
- Rolled out new services like Drive Up with Starbucks and Returns with Drive Up
- Continued to invest in new owned brands, designer collaborations, and store remodels/expansions
- Increased team member wages and benefits
Risk Factors:
- Inability to positively differentiate the customer experience or adapt to changing consumer preferences
- Damage to Target's reputation and brand from negative incidents or failure to meet stakeholder expectations
- Challenges in protecting against inventory shrink and managing elevated inventory levels
- Disruptions to technology systems, cybersecurity/data privacy incidents, and reliance on third-party service providers
- Exposure to macroeconomic conditions, inflation, and changes in trade/tax policies
- Legal and regulatory compliance risks, including labor and employment matters
Legal Matters:
- A purported federal securities class action lawsuit was previously filed against Target and certain officers, but was subsequently dismissed by the court
Management's Discussion and Analysis:
- Total revenue declined 1.6% in fiscal 2023, driven by a 3.7% decrease in comparable sales
- Gross margin rate improved to 26.5% in fiscal 2023 due to lower freight and fulfillment costs, partially offset by higher inventory shrink
- SG&A expense rate increased to 20.1% in fiscal 2023 due to cost inflation and sales deleverage
- Operating cash flow increased 114.6% in fiscal 2023 due to higher earnings and improved working capital
- Target maintained a disciplined capital allocation approach, investing in growth initiatives while returning cash to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases
Earnings calls
Add to research
Earnings Report 2025Q1 (2024-05-22)
Key takeaways
- Target's Q1 2024 financial performance was largely in line with expectations, with comparable sales declining 3.7% and EPS of $2.03, up 33% from Q1 2019 but below the company's long-term goals.
- The company saw continued strength in Beauty and improvement in Apparel, as well as growth in digital sales driven by same-day services like Drive Up.
- Gross margins improved due to cost savings, while SG&A increased due to higher compensation, benefits, and marketing costs.
- Target remains cautious in its near-term growth outlook due to ongoing consumer uncertainty and pressure on discretionary spending, but is confident in its long-term vision and ability to deliver profitable growth.
- The company is focused on operational excellence, agility, and delivering value and convenience to customers, as evidenced by its price investment initiatives and continued investment in the Target Circle loyalty program and digital marketplace.
- Management emphasized the importance of a balanced approach, with a focus on driving top-line growth while maintaining profitability through operational efficiency and cost management.
Summary
-
Financial Performance:
- Total revenue declined 3.1% in Q1 2024, with comparable sales down 3.7% driven by softness in Home and Hardlines categories.
- Earnings per share (EPS) of $2.03 in Q1, up 33% compared to Q1 2019 but below the company's long-term expectations.
- The company met the midpoint of its Q1 guidance range for both comparable sales and EPS.
-
Revenue Drivers:
- Continued strength in Beauty, with low single-digit growth, and improvement in Apparel, which saw a nearly 4 percentage point improvement in comparable sales from Q4.
- Digital sales grew 1.4% in Q1, driven by continued growth in same-day services like Drive Up.
- The relaunch of the Target Circle loyalty program added over 1 million new members in Q1.
-
Profit Margins and Cost Management:
- Gross margin rate improved by about 140 basis points year-over-year, driven by favorable freight rates and other cost savings.
- SG&A rate increased by 130 basis points due to the deleveraging effect of lower sales and higher costs for compensation, benefits, and marketing.
- The company continues to focus on operational efficiencies and inventory management to offset cost pressures.
-
Guidance and Outlook:
- The company expects a comparable sales increase of 0% to 2% in Q2 and for the full year, with EPS guidance of $1.95 to $2.35 in Q2 and $8.60 to $9.60 for the full year.
- The company remains cautious in its near-term growth outlook due to continued consumer uncertainty and pressure on discretionary spending.
-
Strategic Initiatives:
- Announced price cuts on 1,500 frequently shopped items, with plans to expand to 5,000 items this summer.
- Continued investment in the relaunch of the Target Circle loyalty program and expansion of the Target Plus digital marketplace.
- Exploring opportunities to expand the reach of Target's owned brands, such as the launch of Cat & Jack in Canada through a partnership with Hudson's Bay.
-
Management Commentary:
- CEO Brian Cornell expressed confidence in the company's long-term vision and ability to deliver profitable growth, despite the near-term challenges.
- Management highlighted the team's focus on operational excellence, agility, and delivering value and convenience to customers.
-
Industry and Market Conditions:
- The company sees continued consumer resilience in the face of high prices and interest rates, with a normalization of spending patterns between discretionary and frequency categories.
- Inflation has moderated, but the company remains cautious about the near-term outlook due to ongoing economic uncertainty.
-
Q&A Session Highlights:
- Analysts questioned the balance between driving top-line growth and maintaining profitability, as well as the impact of the company's price investment initiatives.
- Management emphasized the importance of a balanced approach, with a focus on operational efficiency, inventory management, and delivering value to customers.
Comparative analysis
Add to research
Benchmarks (as of 2025-02-07)
Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY)
- Performance Comparison: TGT has consistently underperformed XLY over the past three years, with significant underperformance in the 6-month, 1-year, 2-year, and 3-year periods. This suggests that TGT has struggled to keep pace with the broader consumer discretionary sector.
- Risk and Return Analysis: TGT has provided lower annualized returns than XLY over the past three years, with annualized returns of -13.02% for TGT compared to 6.97% for XLY. This indicates that TGT has been a less profitable investment than XLY. TGT has also been more volatile than XLY, with higher annualized volatility. This suggests that TGT's price movements have been more erratic and unpredictable than XLY's. TGT has also experienced significantly larger maximum drawdowns than XLY, with a maximum drawdown of 58.87% compared to XLY's maximum drawdown of 39.67%. This indicates that TGT is more susceptible to significant price declines than XLY.
- Risk-Adjusted Performance: XLY has consistently offered a better risk-adjusted return than TGT, as evidenced by its higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that XLY has been a more efficient investment than TGT, generating higher returns for a given level of risk. XLY's higher beta indicates that it is more sensitive to market movements than TGT. This suggests that XLY is a riskier investment than TGT.
- Overall Assessment: TGT has underperformed XLY in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns over the past three years. TGT has also been more volatile and susceptible to larger drawdowns than XLY. This suggests that TGT is a riskier investment than XLY, with a less attractive risk-reward profile. Investors seeking exposure to the consumer discretionary sector may find XLY to be a more attractive investment option than TGT, given its superior performance, lower volatility, and better risk-adjusted returns.
Peers Price History(as of 2025-02-07)
- Performance Comparison:
- Target Corp. (TGT) has significantly underperformed its peer companies, Walmart, Inc. (WMT) and Costco Wholesale Corp. (COST), over all historical periods. This underperformance is particularly pronounced over the longer timeframes, with TGT's returns lagging behind WMT and COST by a substantial margin.
- TGT's performance has been inconsistent relative to its peers, with periods of outperformance interspersed with periods of significant underperformance. This inconsistency suggests that TGT's business model may be more susceptible to market fluctuations and economic downturns.
- Risk and Return Analysis:
- TGT has provided lower annualized returns than both WMT and COST over the past three years. This suggests that TGT's business model may be less efficient at generating returns for shareholders.
- TGT has exhibited higher annualized volatility than both WMT and COST, indicating a higher level of risk associated with TGT's stock. This higher volatility suggests that TGT's stock price is more likely to fluctuate in response to market movements and economic conditions.
- TGT has experienced the largest maximum drawdown among the three companies, indicating a higher risk of experiencing substantial price declines. This suggests that TGT's business model may be more vulnerable to economic downturns and market shocks.
- Risk-Adjusted Performance:
- COST has consistently offered a better risk-adjusted return than TGT and WMT, as evidenced by its consistently higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that COST's business model is more efficient at generating returns for shareholders while managing risk.
- TGT's higher beta suggests that it is a riskier investment than WMT and COST, as its stock price is more sensitive to market movements. This higher sensitivity to market fluctuations could make TGT's stock less attractive to investors seeking a more stable investment.
- Overall Assessment:
- TGT has consistently underperformed its peer companies, WMT and COST, in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns. This underperformance is likely due to a combination of factors, including TGT's struggles to maintain profitability in a challenging economic environment, its ongoing efforts to adapt to changing consumer preferences, and its focus on digital transformation.
- TGT's higher volatility and larger maximum drawdown suggest that it is a riskier investment than its peers. This higher risk profile may make TGT's stock less attractive to investors seeking a more stable investment.
- COST has consistently outperformed TGT and WMT on a risk-adjusted basis, as evidenced by its consistently higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that COST's business model is more efficient at generating returns for shareholders while managing risk.
- Investors considering an investment in TGT should carefully weigh the company's underperformance, higher risk profile, and ongoing challenges against its potential for future growth and profitability.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2024-10-31)
-
Market Position and Size:
- TGT is a significantly smaller company than its peers, Walmart (WMT) and Costco (COST), with a market cap and key financial metrics that are a fraction of those of its larger competitors. TGT's market cap is approximately 8% of WMT's and 14% of COST's. TGT's revenue is approximately 16% of WMT's and 42% of COST's. TGT's EBITDA is approximately 22% of WMT's and 76% of COST's. TGT's net income is approximately 22% of WMT's and 58% of COST's.
-
Profitability and Efficiency:
- Despite being a significantly smaller company, TGT demonstrates strong profitability metrics, exceeding its peers in Gross Profit Margin, EBITDA Margin, and Net Profit Margin. TGT's profitability is particularly impressive when compared to the industry average, indicating a strong ability to manage costs and generate profits. TGT also demonstrates strong efficiency in generating returns, exceeding its peers in Return on Average Total Equity and exceeding the industry average in all return metrics. This suggests that TGT is effectively utilizing its assets and capital to generate profits.
-
Financial Health and Stability:
- TGT's liquidity metrics are below the industry average, indicating a potential vulnerability to short-term financial pressures. However, TGT's debt metrics are also below the industry average, suggesting a relatively healthy debt position. TGT's overall financial health is characterized by strong profitability and efficiency, a relatively healthy debt position, but lower growth rates and cash flow generation compared to its peers.
-
Valuation and Market Perception:
- TGT's valuation metrics are significantly lower than its peers and the industry average, suggesting that the market is valuing TGT at a discount compared to its competitors. This could be due to TGT's smaller size, lower growth rates, or perceived higher risk.
-
Cash Flow and Capital Management:
- Despite being a smaller company, TGT's cash flow generation is significantly lower than its peers, suggesting that TGT may have less flexibility in investing in growth or returning capital to shareholders.
-
Growth and Future Prospects:
- TGT's growth rates are generally lower than the peer group average, particularly in sales, EBITDA, net income, and basic earnings per share. However, TGT's growth rates in free cash flow and free cash flow margin are significantly higher than the peer group average. TGT's year-over-year growth rates exhibit significant fluctuations, particularly in free cash flow and free cash flow margin, indicating a potential lack of consistency in growth. TGT's 3-year CAGRs are generally lower than its 5-year CAGRs, suggesting that TGT's growth has been accelerating in recent years. However, TGT's 3-year and 5-year CAGRs are generally lower than the peer group average, indicating that TGT's growth is lagging behind its peers. TGT's growth is concentrated in free cash flow and free cash flow margin, while other metrics show slower growth. This suggests that TGT may be focusing on improving its cash flow generation, potentially at the expense of revenue growth. TGT's growth profile is characterized by lower growth rates compared to peers, significant fluctuations in year-over-year growth, and a concentration of growth in free cash flow and free cash flow margin. This suggests that TGT may be facing challenges in sustaining consistent growth across all metrics.
-
Potential for Investment:
- TGT's investment attractiveness is mixed. While TGT demonstrates strong profitability and efficiency, its lower growth rates and cash flow generation compared to its peers raise concerns about its future prospects. TGT's lower valuation compared to its peers may present an opportunity for investors seeking value, but it also reflects the market's perception of its growth potential and financial stability.
-
Key Risks and Considerations:
- TGT's lower growth rates and cash flow generation compared to its peers are key risks for investors. TGT's smaller size and lower growth rates may also make it more vulnerable to economic downturns or changes in consumer spending patterns.
-
Overall Assessment:
- TGT is a profitable and efficient company with a relatively healthy debt position. However, its lower growth rates and cash flow generation compared to its peers raise concerns about its future prospects. TGT's lower valuation compared to its peers reflects the market's perception of its growth potential and financial stability. Investors should carefully consider these factors before making an investment decision.
Comparison metrics
Add to research