Key takeaways
View moreWhile Visa demonstrates strong financial performance and maintains a dominant market position with multiple growth vectors, its current valuation appears slightly elevated given the combination of regulatory risks and increasing competitive pressures. The EV/Sales ratio of 18.50x versus the industry average of 9.12x, coupled with a weakening current ratio and declining net profit margins, suggests the market may be pricing in too optimistic a scenario given the evolving risk landscape.
- Visa's net profit margin, while significantly above the industry average, has decreased from 54.57% in the quarter ending September 30, 2024, to 47.22% in the quarter ending March 31, 2025, indicating a potential concern.
- The current ratio has decreased from 1.37 as of June 30, 2024, to 1.08 as of March 31, 2025, signaling a weakening liquidity position that requires close monitoring.
- Visa's Enterprise Value to Sales ratio of 18.50 is significantly higher than the industry average of 9.12, suggesting that the company may be overvalued relative to its sales.
- Ongoing legal battles, particularly the interchange multidistrict litigation with $1.5 billion accrued as of March 2025, pose a major financial and operational risk.
- Visa's stock has generally outperformed the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over the past three years, with a YTD return of 12.61% compared to 4.01% for XLF.
- Visa is focused on expanding credentials and acceptance, driving user engagement, and displacing cash in key markets like India, Mexico, and Brazil, which supports continued revenue growth.
- Value-added services revenue grew 22% in constant dollars, driven by deepening relationships with existing customers and attracting new customers with recently acquired assets, indicating a successful diversification strategy.
- Visa's debt-to-equity ratio of 54.59% is significantly below the industry average of 703.14%, indicating a relatively conservative capital structure.
- Macroeconomic uncertainty, including potential impacts from tariffs, currency weaknesses, and geopolitical tensions, presents significant risks to Visa's outlook and requires careful scenario planning.
- Visa's management maintains its full-year guidance for adjusted revenue growth and adjusted EPS growth, indicating confidence in the company's business model and strategy.
Evaluation summary
Add to research
-
Company Overview:
- Visa, Inc. (V) is a global payments technology company facilitating commerce through the transfer of value and information among consumers, merchants, financial institutions, businesses, strategic partners, and government entities.
- Key products and services include transaction processing (authorization, clearing, settlement), payment products (credit, debit, prepaid), and value-added services (issuing solutions, acceptance solutions, risk/identity solutions, open banking, advisory services). Visa operates one of the world's largest electronic payments networks, VisaNet, and partners with nearly 14,500 financial institutions globally.
- Benchmarks used for comparative analysis include the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF). Peers include Mastercard, Inc. (MA) and American Express Co. (AXP).
-
Financial Performance:
- Visa's revenue has shown consistent growth. For example, revenue was $9.594 billion for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, compared to $8.9 billion for the quarter ending June 30, 2024.
- The gross profit margin remains strong, at 77.21% for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, slightly above the industry average of 60.22%.
- Net income for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, was $4.53 billion, compared to $5.248 billion for the quarter ending September 30, 2024, indicating a recent decrease in net income.
- The net profit margin was 47.22% for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, significantly above the industry average of -14.65%, but down from 54.57% in the quarter ending September 30, 2024.
- Return on Average Assets was 21.21% for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, significantly higher than the industry average of 0.38%. Return on Average Total Equity was 50.03%, far exceeding the industry average of 3.29%. Return on Average Total Capital was 42.29%, also significantly above the industry average of 6.93%.
-
Operational Efficiency:
- Total current assets were $32.934 billion as of March 31, 2025, compared to $31.039 billion as of June 30, 2024. Total current liabilities were $30.381 billion as of March 31, 2025, compared to $22.612 billion as of June 30, 2024.
- Working capital decreased from $8.427 billion as of June 30, 2024, to $2.553 billion as of March 31, 2025, indicating a potential weakening in short-term liquidity.
- Net operating cash flow was $4.695 billion for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, compared to $5.134 billion for the quarter ending June 30, 2024.
- Free cash flow to equity was $4.368 billion for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, compared to $4.734 billion for the quarter ending June 30, 2024.
- Total capital expenditure was $327 million for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, while depreciation, depletion, and amortization were $305 million.
- Cash dividends paid were $1.164 billion for the quarter ending March 31, 2025. Change in capital stock was -$4.477 billion, indicating share repurchases.
- The current ratio was 1.08 as of March 31, 2025, down from 1.37 as of June 30, 2024, and below the industry average of 2.15.
- The debt-to-equity ratio was 54.59% as of March 31, 2025, compared to 51.86% as of June 30, 2024, and significantly below the industry average of 703.14%.
-
Growth Opportunities:
- Visa is focused on expanding credentials and acceptance, driving user engagement, and displacing cash in key markets like India, Mexico, and Brazil.
- The company is experiencing significant growth in tokenization, reaching 13.7 billion tokens globally, with nearly 50% of e-commerce transactions tokenized.
- Visa is driving cash digitization through Tap to Phone and Tap to Pay, with increasing penetration in various markets.
- The company is expanding interoperability and programmability in stablecoin offerings, including a first seven-day-a-week stablecoin settlement and the development of the Visa tokenized asset platform.
- Visa is seeing strong results in commercial volume, Visa Direct transactions, and CMS revenue, driven by product innovations and strategic partnerships.
- Value-added services revenue grew 22% in constant dollars, driven by deepening relationships with existing customers and attracting new customers with recently acquired assets.
- Visa is evolving the Visa as a Service stack to offer componentized capabilities to a broader array of customers and partners.
-
Recent Developments and Market Sentiment:
- Visa's performance is heavily reliant on the continued resilience of consumer spending, both domestically and internationally.
- The strong growth in value-added services indicates successful diversification and the ability to generate revenue beyond traditional payment processing.
- Volatility in cross-border volumes and the various factors impacting international transaction revenue (FX, client mix, hedging) require close monitoring.
- The success of Visa's strategic initiatives, such as expanding tokenization, Tap to Everything, and Visa Direct, is crucial for maintaining its competitive edge and driving future growth.
- Macroeconomic uncertainty, including potential impacts from tariffs, currency weaknesses, and geopolitical tensions, presents significant risks to Visa's outlook.
-
Risks and Threats:
- Increased regulatory scrutiny and restrictions on interchange fees, network rules, and operating practices could impact Visa's revenue and profitability.
- Government-imposed market access barriers and domestic processing requirements in certain countries pose a risk.
- Evolving data privacy, cybersecurity, and AI regulations could increase compliance costs.
- Intense competition from existing and emerging payments providers, including potential disintermediation, is a significant threat.
- Reliance on financial institution clients and merchants, who could reduce or terminate relationships, is a risk.
- Ongoing interchange multidistrict litigation, with $1.5 billion accrued as of March 2025, poses a major financial and operational risk.
- A U.S. Department of Justice antitrust lawsuit alleges Visa has monopolized debit network services.
-
Valuation Analysis:
- The Enterprise Value to EBITDA ratio was 26.28 for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, higher than the quarter ending September 30, 2024, at 21.96, but lower than the industry average of 41.67.
- The Enterprise Value to Sales ratio was 18.50 for the quarter ending March 31, 2025, higher than the quarter ending September 30, 2024, at 15.42, and significantly higher than the industry average of 9.12.
-
Price Performance:
- Visa's stock price has generally increased from $330.78 on April 16, 2025, to $373.31 on June 11, 2025. However, it closed at $352.85 on June 13, 2025.
- Visa has generally outperformed the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over the past three years. As of the latest data, V has outperformed XLF year-to-date (YTD) by 8.6%, with returns of 12.61% compared to 4.01% for XLF.
- Visa has generally outperformed Mastercard (MA) across most periods, but has underperformed American Express (AXP) over longer time horizons (2 and 3 years).
-
Future Outlook:
- Visa maintained its full-year guidance for adjusted revenue growth, adjusted operating expense growth, non-operating income, tax rate, and adjusted EPS growth.
- The company assumes Q3 and Q4 cross-border volume growth will be slightly below Q4 2024 levels.
- They anticipate higher incentive growth in the back half of the year due to client performance adjustments and deal timing.
- Q3 adjusted net revenue growth is expected in the low-double-digits, with adjusted EPS growth in the high-teens.
-
Summary:
- Visa exhibits strong financial performance with consistent revenue growth and high profitability, significantly above industry averages.
- The company's operational efficiency is showing signs of weakening liquidity, requiring close monitoring of working capital management.
- Growth opportunities are abundant, driven by strategic initiatives in tokenization, Tap to Everything, and value-added services.
- Key risks include increased regulatory scrutiny, intense competition, and ongoing legal battles, which could impact long-term growth and profitability.
- Visa's valuation metrics are high compared to industry averages, reflecting investor confidence in its growth potential.
- The company's financial health remains strong, but its ability to navigate regulatory challenges and competitive pressures will be critical for future success.
- Visa presents a balanced investment profile with high growth potential offset by significant regulatory and competitive risks.
Price history
Add to research
Fundamentals
Add to research
Insights
- Visa maintains a strong market position and consistent revenue growth, driven by increasing processed transactions, cross-border volume, and payments volume.
- The company's profitability remains strong, supported by a high gross profit margin and effective expense management, but the recent decrease in net income warrants attention.
- Visa's liquidity position is weakening, as indicated by the decreasing current ratio and cash and short-term investments, requiring close monitoring.
- The company faces significant regulatory risks, intense competition, and ongoing legal battles, which could impact its long-term growth and profitability.
- Visa is committed to returning value to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases, while also managing its debt levels and investing in innovation.
Analysis
- Revenue
- Visa's revenue has shown consistent growth, driven by increases in processed transactions, cross-border volume, and payments volume.
- The company's focus on expanding credentials and acceptance, driving user engagement, and displacing cash in key markets like India, Mexico, and Brazil, as highlighted in the earnings call, supports continued revenue growth.
- The SEC filings also mention that revenue growth is driven by increases in processed transactions, cross-border volume, and payments volume, which aligns with the income statement trends.
- Profitability
- Visa maintains strong profitability, supported by a high gross profit margin and effective expense management.
- The net profit margin, while decreasing, remains significantly above the industry average, indicating a strong ability to generate profit relative to revenue.
- The company's focus on value-added services, as highlighted in the earnings call, could contribute to future revenue growth and margin expansion.
- Liquidity
- The decreasing current ratio indicates a potential weakening in short-term liquidity, requiring close monitoring.
- The company's cash and short-term investments have been decreasing, which could impact its ability to quickly fund opportunities or weather financial downturns.
- Management's focus on maintaining a strong liquidity position, as highlighted in the SEC filings, is crucial given the decreasing current ratio.
- Solvency
- The moderate debt-to-equity ratio suggests a balanced capital structure, but the increasing trend warrants attention.
- The company's long-term debt has been decreasing, suggesting a focus on deleveraging and strengthening the balance sheet.
- The debt/EBITDA ratio suggests that Visa can easily cover its debt obligations with its earnings.
- Operational Efficiency
- Increasing accounts receivable suggest the need for efficient asset utilization to convert receivables into cash.
- The company's investments in intangible assets, likely due to acquisitions and investments in technology, align with its strategy to expand its service offerings.
- The enterprise value to sales ratio indicates how much investors are willing to pay for each dollar of Visa's sales.
- Cash Flow Analysis - Visa generates strong and consistent cash flow from operations, supported by its core profitability and efficient working capital management. - The company is committed to returning value to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. - Capital expenditures appear to be aligned with the company's growth strategy, supporting innovation and expansion.
- Risk Factors
- Increased regulatory scrutiny and restrictions on interchange fees, network rules, and operating practices, as highlighted in the SEC filings, could impact Visa's revenue and profitability.
- Intense competition from existing and emerging payments providers, including potential disintermediation, could also pose a threat to Visa's market position.
- Ongoing legal battles, particularly the high-stakes interchange multidistrict litigation, pose a major financial and operational risk.
- Future Outlook
- Visa's future outlook remains positive, supported by its strong market position, consistent revenue growth, and commitment to innovation.
- The company's focus on expanding into new flows and value-added services, as well as its strong liquidity position, should enable it to navigate industry disruption and regulatory changes.
- However, the company faces significant regulatory risks, intense competition, and ongoing legal battles, which could impact its long-term growth and profitability.
- Profitability
Financial statements
Add to research
Loading...
Public filings
Add to research
- Visa faces significant regulatory risks, with governments in key markets imposing restrictions on interchange fees, network rules, and domestic processing requirements that could disrupt its business model
- The company is navigating intense competition from emerging payments providers, including real-time payments networks and digital wallets, which could disintermediate Visa's traditional role in the payments ecosystem
- Ongoing legal battles, particularly the high-stakes interchange multidistrict litigation, pose a major financial and operational risk, with over $1.5 billion accrued as of March 2025
- Despite these challenges, Visa continues to grow its core payments volume and transaction processing business, while expanding into new flows and value-added services to diversify its revenue streams
- The company maintains a strong liquidity position and continues to return capital to shareholders through share repurchases and dividends, but its long-term growth and profitability will depend on its ability to adapt to industry disruption and regulatory changes
Core Business and Operations:
- Visa is a global payments technology company that facilitates global commerce and money movement across over 200 countries and territories
- Key products and services include transaction processing (authorization, clearing, settlement), payment products (credit, debit, prepaid), and value-added services (issuing solutions, acceptance solutions, risk/identity solutions, open banking, advisory services)
- Visa operates one of the world's largest electronic payments networks, VisaNet, and partners with nearly 14,500 financial institutions globally
- Major competitors include other global/multi-regional networks (American Express, Mastercard, UnionPay), local/regional networks, alternative payment providers, RTP networks, and digital wallet providers
Industry and Market Trends:
- Payments industry continues to undergo rapid technological change and evolving regulatory landscape
- Governments in some countries are implementing policies to promote domestic payments systems and restrict international networks like Visa
- Increasing regulatory focus on interchange fees, network exclusivity, data privacy/security, and open banking requirements
- Growth of real-time payments networks and central bank digital currencies could disintermediate traditional card networks
Recent Events:
- Acquired Featurespace, a developer of AI-powered payments fraud prevention technology
- Completed class B-1 common stock exchange offer, issuing class B-2 and class C shares
- Continued share repurchase program, with $9.1 billion remaining authorized as of March 2025
- Recorded significant litigation accruals related to the interchange multidistrict litigation
Risk Factors:
- Increased regulatory scrutiny and restrictions on interchange fees, network rules, and operating practices
- Government-imposed market access barriers and domestic processing requirements in certain countries
- Evolving data privacy, cybersecurity, and AI regulations that could increase compliance costs
- Intense competition from existing and emerging payments providers, including potential disintermediation
- Reliance on financial institution clients and merchants, who could reduce or terminate relationships
Legal Matters:
- Ongoing interchange multidistrict litigation, with $1.5 billion accrued as of March 2025
- U.S. Department of Justice antitrust lawsuit alleging Visa has monopolized debit network services
- Various merchant and consumer class actions related to debit card routing and access fees
- Shareholder derivative lawsuits related to alleged antitrust violations
Management's Discussion and Analysis:
- Revenue growth driven by increases in processed transactions, cross-border volume, and payments volume, partially offset by higher client incentives
- Operating expenses increased primarily due to higher litigation provision, personnel, and depreciation/amortization costs
- Effective tax rate fluctuated based on discrete tax items and changes in geographic earnings mix
- Maintained strong liquidity position, with $12.0 billion in cash and investments as of March 2025
- Continued share repurchases and quarterly dividend payments to shareholders
Earnings calls
Add to research
Earnings Report 2025Q2 (2025-04-29)
Key takeaways
- Resilient Consumer Spending is Key: Visa's performance is heavily reliant on the continued resilience of consumer spending, both domestically and internationally. Any significant weakening in consumer spending could negatively impact revenue growth.
- Value-Added Services are a Growth Driver: The strong growth in value-added services is a significant positive, indicating successful diversification and the ability to generate revenue beyond traditional payment processing.
- Cross-Border Volatility Requires Monitoring: The volatility in cross-border volumes and the various factors impacting international transaction revenue (FX, client mix, hedging) require close monitoring and proactive management.
- Strategic Initiatives are Crucial: The success of Visa's strategic initiatives, such as expanding tokenization, Tap to Everything, and Visa Direct, is crucial for maintaining its competitive edge and driving future growth.
- Macroeconomic Uncertainty Presents Risks: The macroeconomic uncertainty, including potential impacts from tariffs, currency weaknesses, and geopolitical tensions, presents significant risks to Visa's outlook and requires careful scenario planning.
Focus of management’s prepared remarks
- Consumer Payments Growth: Expanding credentials and acceptance, driving user engagement, and displacing cash in key markets like India, Mexico, and Brazil.
- Tokenization Expansion: Significant growth in tokenization, reaching 13.7 billion tokens globally, with nearly 50% of e-commerce transactions tokenized.
- Tap to Everything Innovation: Driving cash digitization and habituation through Tap to Phone and Tap to Pay, with increasing penetration in various markets.
- Stablecoin Offerings: Expanding interoperability and programmability in stablecoin offerings, including a first seven-day-a-week stablecoin settlement and the development of the Visa tokenized asset platform.
- Commercial and Money Movement Solutions: Strong results in commercial volume, Visa Direct transactions, and CMS revenue, driven by product innovations and strategic partnerships.
- Value-Added Services Growth: Deepening relationships with existing customers and attracting new customers with recently acquired assets, resulting in strong growth across all portfolios.
- Visa as a Service Evolution: Evolving the Visa as a Service stack to offer componentized capabilities to a broader array of customers and partners, making it easier for them to access Visa's solutions.
- Resilient Consumer Spending: Consumer spending has been resilient and strong, but there's much uncertainty.
- Financial Outlook: The company sees resilience playing out in their financial outlook.
Focus of the analyst Q&A
- Client Decision-Making:
- Whether there have been any noticeable changes in client decision-making, pipelines, or backlogs, particularly among international clients.
- If clients are changing the speed with which they are working with Visa.
- International Travel Bookings:
- What Visa is seeing around international travel bookings and travel generally.
- How Visa is feeling about the travel outlook on a go-forward basis.
- Any insights from early bookings.
- Cross-Border Corridors:
- What assumptions Visa has made for the remainder of the year regarding specific cross-border corridors, particularly the US one.
- The impact of these assumptions on the economic return from each of those corridors.
- Pull-Forward of Spending:
- Whether there was any evidence of a pull-forward of spending in the volumes seen intra-quarter and early in April.
- Value-Added Services Performance:
- How value-added services perform through the cycle, considering the range of revenue models (transaction-based, project-based, recurring/subscription).
- How Visa is thinking about value-added services growth in the back-half of the year.
- Incentives Outlook:
- Clarification on the incentives outlook, given the front-loaded renewal schedule.
- Cadence and drivers of incentive growth over the next two quarters.
- Delta Between Nominal Cross-Border Volumes and Revenue:
- A deeper dive into the delta between nominal cross-border volumes and nominal international revenue.
- The impact of FX volatility, client mix, pricing, and hedging.
- FX Volatility Offset:
- A more detailed explanation of the FX volatility offset by customer mix and hedging.
- What exactly happened with the hedging or mix dynamic.
- US Volume Growth:
- Whether to assume some moderation off the April levels of 8% for US volume growth, given the effects of Easter and potential pull-forward of spending.
- Entertainment Weakness:
- Where the entertainment weakness was seen exactly.
- Whether Visa expects that to continue going forward.
- Geopolitical Backdrop:
- Whether the geopolitical backdrop changes Visa's views of how it's placing investment bets.
- If there are any changes to risk-on payback periods, specific geos, or M&A opportunities.
- Macro Conditions:
- If macro conditions shift materially and much more quickly than expected, what key levers Visa has in terms of revenue (like pricing) or cost management (like marketing) to keep pace with the rate of change and protect margins.
- Stablecoin Settlements:
- What the latest thoughts are on the demand for stablecoin settlements or other stablecoin payments.
- Whether Visa is seeing or expecting an inflection.
- What clients are saying about stablecoins.
- Government Nationalism Risk:
- How Visa thinks about navigating government nationalism risk in the current environment, being a US-based company operating globally during trade disputes.
Summary
-
Financial Performance
Visa reported strong Q2 2025 results, with net revenue of $9.6 billion, up 9% year-over-year, and EPS up 10%. In constant dollars, payments volume grew 8% and cross-border volume (excluding Intra-Europe) increased by 13%. Processed transactions grew 9% year-over-year. The company beat EPS expectations due to stronger operating performance and a lower tax rate.
-
Revenue Drivers
Revenue growth was driven by resilient consumer spending, lower-than-expected client incentives, and better-than-expected value-added services revenue. Key drivers included growth in payments volume, cross-border volume, and process transactions. Value-added services revenue grew 22% in constant dollars. Commercial and money movement solutions revenue grew 13% year-over-year in constant dollars. Total credentials grew 7%, and tokenization efforts continued to expand, with 13.7 billion tokens.
-
Profit Margins and Cost Management
Operating expenses grew 7%, primarily driven by increases in personnel, marketing, and depreciation and amortization. The tax rate for the quarter was 16.9%, lower than expected due to a change in the geographic mix of earnings. The company expects adjusted operating expense growth in the low-double-digits for Q3, relatively consistent with adjusted revenue growth.
-
Guidance and Outlook
Visa maintained its full-year guidance for adjusted revenue growth, adjusted operating expense growth, non-operating income, tax rate, and adjusted EPS growth. The company assumes Q3 and Q4 cross-border volume growth will be slightly below Q4 2024 levels. They anticipate higher incentive growth in the back half of the year due to client performance adjustments and deal timing. Q3 adjusted net revenue growth is expected in the low-double-digits, with adjusted EPS growth in the high-teens.
-
Strategic Initiatives
Visa is focused on expanding credentials and acceptance, driving user engagement, and displacing cash. Key initiatives include Tap to Everything, tokenization, multi-currency cards, and account-to-account solutions. The company is also expanding its Visa Direct platform and value-added services through acquisitions like Featurespace and Pismo. They are evolving their "Visa as a Service" stack to offer componentized capabilities to a broader array of customers and partners.
-
Management Commentary
Management expressed confidence in Visa's business model and strategy, highlighting its resilience in the face of macroeconomic uncertainty. They emphasized a focus on serving clients and capturing opportunities in consumer payments, commercial and money movement solutions, and value-added services. The CEO noted that consumer spending has been resilient, but there is much uncertainty. They are focused on what they can control and stand ready to make thoughtful adjustments when necessary.
-
Industry and Market Conditions
Management noted that consumer spending remains resilient despite macroeconomic uncertainty. They observed stable trends outside the US and some deceleration in travel-related spending. They are monitoring the potential impacts from tariffs and currency weaknesses. The company believes that clear and pragmatic regulations will be a tipping point for stablecoin adoption.
Comparative analysis
Add to research
Benchmarks (as of 2025-06-13)
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF)
- Performance Comparison:
- Visa, Inc. (V) has generally outperformed the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over the past three years. As of the latest data, V has outperformed XLF year-to-date (YTD) by 8.6%, with returns of 12.61% compared to 4.01% for XLF. Over a 3-year period, V has returned 84.04% compared to 66.8% for XLF, indicating a significant outperformance. However, in the short term, such as the past week and month, V has slightly underperformed XLF.
- Risk and Return Analysis:
- Visa, Inc. (V) has provided higher annualized returns compared to the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over the 1, 2, and 3-year periods. The 3-year annualized return for V is 22.55%, while for XLF it is 18.59%.
- Visa, Inc. (V) has generally exhibited higher annualized volatility compared to the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF). For example, in Q2 2022, V's volatility ranged from 33.33% to 37.43%, while XLF's ranged from 27.7% to 29.89%.
- The maximum drawdown for Visa, Inc. (V) was -28.6% on 2022-09-30, while for the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) it was -25.81% on 2022-10-12. This suggests that V experienced slightly larger peak-to-trough declines during the observed period, indicating a potentially higher risk profile.
- Risk-Adjusted Performance:
- The Sharpe Ratio for Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) generally shows higher levels than Visa, Inc. (V) indicating better risk-adjusted returns over the period.
- The Beta value for Visa, Inc. (V) has generally been below 1, indicating lower sensitivity to market movements compared to the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF).
- Overall Assessment:
- Visa, Inc. (V) has demonstrated strong historical performance, outperforming the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over the medium to long term. While V exhibits higher volatility and drawdown, its higher returns have historically compensated for the increased risk. However, the Sharpe Ratio indicates that XLF has better risk-adjusted returns. The lower beta of V suggests it is less sensitive to overall market movements compared to XLF.
- Recent trends indicate that V has shown fluctuating volatility and drawdown, while XLF has been more stable. Investors should consider their risk tolerance and investment horizon when choosing between V and XLF.
Peers Price History(as of 2025-06-13)
-
Performance Comparison:
- Visa (V) has generally outperformed Mastercard (MA) across most periods, but has underperformed American Express (AXP) over longer time horizons (2 and 3 years). For example, the YTD performance shows Visa outperforming Mastercard by 4.69% and American Express by 15.63%. However, over 3 years, Visa's performance is 20.77% lower than American Express.
- Visa's performance is more consistent with Mastercard, while American Express shows periods of both significant outperformance and underperformance relative to Visa.
-
Risk and Return Analysis:
- Visa's annualized returns are generally higher than Mastercard's but lower than American Express's. For instance, over 1 year, Visa's annualized return is 31.07%, compared to Mastercard's 26.16% and American Express's 27.5%.
- Visa's annualized volatility is generally lower than both Mastercard and American Express. In Q2 2025, Visa's volatility was 41.32%, compared to Mastercard's 40.13% and American Express's 62.35%. This indicates Visa is less risky than American Express.
- Visa's maximum drawdown was -28.6% on 2022-09-30, which is less than American Express's -31.55% on 2022-09-30, but similar to Mastercard's -28.25% on 2022-10-12. This suggests Visa has a moderate risk profile.
-
Risk-Adjusted Performance:
- Visa's Sharpe Ratio is generally competitive, but often lower than American Express, indicating that American Express offers better risk-adjusted returns. In Q2 2025, the Sharpe Ratio for Visa was 1.3, while American Express was 1.
- Visa's Beta is consistently below 1, indicating it is less sensitive to market movements compared to American Express, which has a Beta consistently above 1. As of Q2 2025, Visa's Beta is 0.73, while American Express's is 1.31.
-
Overall Assessment:
- Visa offers a balanced profile of performance and risk, outperforming Mastercard but generally underperforming American Express in terms of returns. Visa exhibits lower volatility and a lower Beta, suggesting a more conservative investment. American Express, while offering higher potential returns, comes with higher volatility and drawdowns.
- A key trend is the recent increase in volatility across all three companies in Q2 2025, with American Express showing a significantly higher spike. Additionally, American Express consistently demonstrates higher risk-adjusted returns (Sharpe Ratio) and greater sensitivity to market movements (Beta) compared to Visa and Mastercard.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2025-03-31)
-
Market Position and Size:
- Visa, Inc. (V) holds a dominant market position with the largest market capitalization of $690,613.95 million, significantly surpassing Mastercard, Inc. (MA) at $523,571.09 million and American Express Co. (AXP) at $211,788.05 million.
- This substantial market capitalization is supported by robust financial metrics, including revenue of $37,621 million, EBITDA of $26,476 million, and net income of $19,642 million.
- While American Express has higher revenue at $75,333 million, Visa's superior EBITDA and net income underscore its operational efficiency and profitability.
-
Profitability and Efficiency:
- Visa demonstrates exceptional profitability, with a gross profit margin of 77.1%, exceeding the industry average of 60.22%. Although lower than Mastercard's 96.71%, it is significantly higher than American Express's 60.89%.
- The company's EBITDA margin of 70.38% and net profit margin of 52.21% are substantially higher than both its peers and the industry average (23.29% and -14.65%, respectively), indicating efficient operations and strong earnings relative to its revenue.
- Visa's return on average assets (21.21%), return on average total equity (50.03%), return on average total capital (42.29%), and return on average invested capital (33.89%) are generally higher than American Express and the industry averages, reflecting efficient capital utilization.
-
Financial Health and Stability:
- Visa maintains a strong liquidity and solvency position, characterized by a conservative debt profile and robust cash flow generation.
- Its total debt to total equity ratio of 54.59 is significantly lower than Mastercard's 281.85, American Express's 169.2, and the industry average of 703.14, indicating a more stable and less leveraged financial position.
- Visa's debt/EBITDA ratio of 0.78 is also lower than its peers and the industry average, demonstrating strong debt management relative to earnings.
- The company's cash flow/total debt ratio of 176.63 is significantly higher than its peers and the industry average, indicating a strong ability to cover debt obligations with cash flow.
- However, Visa's current ratio and quick ratio are slightly lower than Mastercard's and below the industry average, suggesting potentially lower liquidity.
-
Valuation and Market Perception:
- Visa's enterprise value to sales (18.5) and price-to-sales ratio (18.69) are higher than its peers and the industry average, suggesting a premium valuation based on sales.
- Its price-to-earnings ratio of 36.22 is lower than Mastercard's 40.45 but higher than American Express's 21.12 and the industry average of 19.32.
- Visa's price-to-book ratio of 18.63 is significantly lower than Mastercard's 78.65 but higher than American Express's 6.79 and the industry average of 3.51.
- These valuation metrics indicate that Visa is perceived as a premium company with strong growth potential and market confidence.
-
Cash Flow and Capital Management:
- Visa demonstrates strong cash flow generation capabilities, with net operating cash flow of $21,889 million and free cash flow of $20,508 million, both exceeding its peers.
- Its total capital expenditure of $1,381 million is higher than Mastercard's but lower than American Express's, reflecting its investment in growth opportunities.
- Visa's cash conversion ratio of 0.96 is lower than Mastercard's 1.39 but higher than American Express's 0.54 and the industry average of 0.6, indicating efficient cash management.
-
Growth and Future Prospect:
- Visa's revenue, EBITDA, and net income growth rates have fluctuated significantly year-to-year.
- Its 3-year CAGR is greater than its 5-year CAGR for sales/revenue, EBITDA, net income, and basic earnings per share, indicating a recent acceleration in growth for these metrics.
- However, its free cash flow growth has been decelerating, with a lower recent year-over-year growth rate compared to its 5-year CAGR.
- Visa's competitive position is strong in terms of profitability and market capitalization, but its growth in free cash flow lags behind its peers.
-
Potential for Investment:
- Visa presents an attractive investment opportunity due to its dominant market position, strong profitability, conservative debt profile, and robust cash flow generation.
- While its valuation metrics indicate a premium valuation, its growth potential and financial stability justify the higher price.
- However, investors should be mindful of its decelerating free cash flow growth and lower liquidity ratios compared to industry averages.
-
Key Risks and Considerations:
- Visa's decelerating free cash flow growth could be a potential concern, as it may indicate challenges in sustaining its growth trajectory.
- Its lower liquidity ratios compared to industry averages may pose risks in meeting short-term obligations.
- Fluctuations in revenue, EBITDA, and net income growth rates may create uncertainty for investors.
-
Overall Assessment:
- Visa exhibits strong financial health, characterized by its dominant market position, superior profitability, conservative debt profile, and robust cash flow generation.
- While its liquidity ratios are slightly below the industry average and its earnings per share are lower than some peers, its overall financial stability and performance are commendable.
- Visa holds a leading competitive position within its peer group and the broader industry, driven by its superior market capitalization, strong profitability, and efficient operations.
Comparison metrics
Add to research