Thematic evaluation
Back to company overview

MSCI, Inc. (MSCI)

October 08, 2024

Compared to: Moody's Corp. (MCO) | Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. (ICE) | Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLK)

Our reasoning

MSCI's current valuation appears moderately overvalued based on its high P/E and EV/EBITDA multiples compared to historical averages and industry peers. While the company demonstrates strong financial performance, growth prospects, and market position, the current valuation seems to be pricing in overly optimistic expectations, leaving little room for potential setbacks or slower-than-expected growth.

Key takeaways
  • MSCI is a leading provider of critical investment tools and solutions, with a strong track record of financial performance and growth.
  • The company is well-positioned to benefit from key industry trends, such as the growth of indexed investing, increased demand for ESG and climate data, and the expansion of private asset allocations.
  • MSCI's recent acquisitions and strategic initiatives are expected to drive further growth and strengthen its competitive positioning.
  • While MSCI faces operational, financial, and regulatory risks, its strong financial performance, profitability, and liquidity position it well to navigate these challenges.
  • MSCI's valuation is currently at a premium compared to its peers, reflecting its strong growth prospects and market position.
  • The company's stock price has underperformed its benchmark and peers, but its future outlook remains positive, with expectations for continued growth and profitability.
  • Investors should carefully consider MSCI's risk profile, including its reliance on third-party data, client concentration, and cybersecurity threats, before making any investment decisions.
Overvalued
Ask a question about MSCI, Inc. (MSCI)
Evaluation summary

  1. Company Overview:

    • MSCI is a leading provider of investment decision support tools, including indexes, portfolio risk and performance analytics, and ESG and climate products and services. The company operates through four segments: Index, Analytics, ESG and Climate, and All Other-Private Assets.
    • MSCI's key products and services include:
      • Indexes: MSCI develops and maintains a wide range of equity, fixed income, and real asset indices, which are used by investors to track market performance, construct portfolios, and create financial products.
      • Analytics: MSCI offers a suite of risk management, performance attribution, and portfolio management tools and services to help investors understand and manage their investments.
      • ESG and Climate: MSCI provides data, ratings, research, and tools to help investors integrate ESG and climate considerations into their investment processes.
      • Private Assets: MSCI offers data and analytics for private equity, real estate, and infrastructure investments.
    • MSCI's target market includes asset owners, asset managers, financial intermediaries, wealth managers, real estate professionals, and corporates.
    • The company's key competitors include S&P Dow Jones Indices, FTSE Russell, Solactive, Nasdaq, and Bloomberg.
    • For comparative analysis, we will be using Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLK) as a benchmark and Moody's Corp. (MCO) and Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. (ICE) as industry peers.

  2. Financial Performance:

    • MSCI has demonstrated strong revenue growth in recent quarters, driven by increasing demand for its products and services, particularly in the Index, ESG and Climate, and Private Assets segments.
    • The company's profitability has also been strong, with expanding margins and a high net profit margin.
    • MSCI's return on average assets (ROA), return on average total equity (ROE), and return on average invested capital (ROIC) have been consistently high, indicating efficient asset utilization and strong profitability.
    • Compared to its peers, MSCI has underperformed both MCO and ICE in terms of revenue growth, profitability, and stock price appreciation.

  3. Operational Efficiency:

    • MSCI's balance sheet has shown a trend of increasing intangible assets, which could indicate a shift in investment strategy towards growth initiatives.
    • The company's working capital has been decreasing, which could indicate a need for more working capital in the future.
    • MSCI's cash flow generation has been strong, with a high net operating cash flow and a high free cash flow to equity.
    • The company's capital expenditure has been relatively stable, while depreciation has been increasing, indicating a focus on maintaining and expanding its infrastructure.
    • MSCI has a history of paying dividends and repurchasing shares, demonstrating its commitment to shareholder returns.
    • Compared to its peers, MSCI has a lower current ratio and a higher debt-to-equity ratio, indicating a higher level of financial risk.

  4. Growth Opportunities:

    • MSCI is well-positioned to benefit from key industry trends, including the growth of indexed investing, increased demand for ESG and climate data, and the expansion of private asset allocations.
    • The company has made strategic acquisitions to expand its capabilities in private assets, carbon markets intelligence, and wealth management technology.
    • MSCI is investing in research, product development, and technology to drive innovation and enhance its offerings.
    • The company has launched new initiatives, such as private capital indices, a partnership with Moody's, and AI-powered solutions, to further drive growth and strengthen its competitive positioning.
    • MSCI's capital allocation strategy appears to be focused on a balance of organic growth, M&A, and shareholder returns.

  5. Risks and Threats:

    • MSCI faces a number of risks, including:
      • Reliance on third-party data, applications, and services, which could lead to disruptions or terminations.
      • Errors or defects in products, which could lead to increased costs or liability.
      • Reputational and credibility concerns related to index composition, ESG ratings, and other content.
      • Client concentration and potential loss of large clients or renegotiation of fee structures.
      • Cybersecurity threats and failures in information technology systems.
      • Competition and pricing pressures from industry participants.
      • Regulatory changes and compliance risks, particularly around ESG and indexes.
    • The company's industry is subject to macroeconomic factors, such as interest rate changes and market volatility, which could impact its performance.

  6. Valuation Analysis:

    • MSCI's valuation metrics, such as P/E ratio and EV/EBITDA, are relatively high compared to its peers, indicating a premium valuation.
    • The company's high valuation is likely driven by its strong growth prospects and its position as a leading provider of critical investment tools and solutions.
    • Potential catalysts for MSCI's valuation include continued growth in the Index, ESG and Climate, and Private Assets segments, as well as successful execution of its strategic initiatives.

  7. Price Performance:

    • MSCI's stock price has underperformed both its benchmark, XLK, and its peers, MCO and ICE, over the past three years.
    • The company's stock price has exhibited higher volatility than both XLK and its peers, indicating a higher risk profile.
    • MSCI's beta value has been consistently above 1, suggesting that its stock price is more sensitive to market movements than the overall market.

  8. Future Outlook:

    • MSCI's management has expressed confidence in the company's ability to drive compounding growth and profitability for shareholders.
    • The company's strategic initiatives are expected to drive further growth and strengthen its competitive positioning.
    • Analyst estimates for MSCI's future performance are generally positive, with expectations for continued revenue growth and profitability.

  9. Summary:

    • MSCI is a leading provider of critical investment tools and solutions, with a focus on indexes, analytics, ESG/climate, and private assets.
    • The company is well-positioned to benefit from key industry trends, including the growth of indexed investing, increased demand for ESG and climate data, and the expansion of private asset allocations.
    • MSCI has demonstrated strong financial performance, profitability, and liquidity to support its growth initiatives and shareholder returns.
    • The company's focus on innovation, client relationships, and strategic partnerships positions it well to navigate the evolving investment landscape and capitalize on emerging opportunities.
    • While MSCI faces operational, financial, and regulatory risks, its strong financial performance, profitability, and liquidity position it well to navigate these challenges.
    • MSCI's valuation is currently at a premium compared to its peers, reflecting its strong growth prospects and market position.
    • The company's stock price has underperformed its benchmark and peers, but its future outlook remains positive, with expectations for continued growth and profitability.
Peer fundamentals 
Fundamentals
Insights
  • MSCI is a leading provider of critical investment tools and solutions, with a focus on indexes, analytics, ESG/climate, and private assets.
  • The company is well-positioned to benefit from key industry trends, including the growth of indexed investing, increased demand for ESG and climate data, and the expansion of private asset allocations.
  • Recent acquisitions have strengthened MSCI's capabilities in private assets, carbon markets intelligence, and wealth management technology, further enhancing its comprehensive offerings.
  • MSCI has demonstrated strong financial performance, profitability, and liquidity to support its growth initiatives and shareholder returns.
  • The company's focus on innovation, client relationships, and strategic partnerships positions it well to navigate the evolving investment landscape and capitalize on emerging opportunities.
  • While MSCI faces operational, financial, and regulatory risks, its strong financial performance, profitability, and liquidity position it well to navigate these challenges.
Analysis
  • Revenue - MSCI's revenue growth is strong and sustainable, driven by the increasing demand for its products and services. - The company's recent acquisitions, such as the acquisition of Burgiss, Trove Research, Fabric RQ, and Foxberry, have likely contributed to the increase in revenue. - The increasing demand for ESG and climate data, as well as the growth of private asset allocations, have likely contributed to the increase in revenue. - The increasing regulation around ESG and indexes has likely contributed to the increase in revenue.
    • Profitability
      • MSCI's profitability is strong, with expanding margins and a high net profit margin.
      • The company's focus on higher-margin products and services, such as ESG and climate solutions and private asset data and analysis, has likely contributed to the expansion of margins.
      • The company's effective expense control has also contributed to the expansion of margins.
    • Liquidity
      • MSCI's liquidity position appears to be strong, with a current ratio of 0.95, which is slightly lower than the industry average.
      • However, the company's working capital is decreasing, which could indicate a need for more working capital in the future.
    • Solvency
      • MSCI's long-term solvency appears to be strong, with a decreasing debt / EBITDA ratio and a decreasing total debt to total equity ratio.
      • The company's focus on reducing leverage and improving financial stability has likely contributed to the decrease in debt / EBITDA ratio and total debt to total equity ratio.
    • Operational Efficiency
      • MSCI's asset utilization efficiency is high, with a strong return on average assets and a strong return on average total capital.
      • The company's focus on investing in research, product development, and technology to drive innovation has likely contributed to the high asset utilization efficiency.
    • Cash Flow Analysis
      • MSCI's cash flow generation is strong, with a high net operating cash flow and a high free cash flow to equity.
      • The company's strong profitability and its focus on growth have likely contributed to the strong cash flow generation.
      • The company's capital allocation strategy appears to be focused on a balance of organic growth, M&A, and shareholder returns.
    • Risk Factors
      • The decreasing cash and short-term investments could indicate a need for more working capital in the future.
      • The increasing intangible assets could indicate a shift in investment strategy, which could be risky if the investments do not generate a return.
      • The company's reliance on third-party data, applications, and services could lead to disruptions or terminations.
      • Errors or defects in products could lead to increased costs or liability.
      • Reputational and credibility concerns related to index composition, ESG ratings, and other content could damage the company's business.
      • Client concentration and potential loss of large clients or renegotiation of fee structures could negatively impact the company's revenue.
      • Cybersecurity threats and failures in information technology systems could disrupt the company's operations and damage its reputation.
      • Competition and pricing pressures from industry participants could erode the company's profitability.
      • Regulatory changes and compliance risks, particularly around ESG and indexes, could increase the company's costs and complexity.
    • Future Outlook
      • MSCI is well-positioned to continue to grow its business in the future, driven by the increasing demand for its products and services, its focus on higher-margin products and services, and its effective expense control.
      • The company's strategic initiatives, such as the launch of private capital indices, the partnership with Moody's, and the development of AI-powered solutions, are expected to drive further growth and strengthen MSCI's competitive positioning.
      • However, the company faces a number of risks, including competition, regulatory changes, and cybersecurity threats.
Most recent earnings report
Financial statements 
All public filings
Comparative Analysis
Benchmarks (as of 2024-09-12)
Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLK)
  • Performance Comparison: MSCI has consistently underperformed XLK over the past three years, with significant underperformance in the longer timeframes. This suggests that XLK has been a better investment choice for investors seeking growth.
  • Risk and Return Analysis: While MSCI has provided lower returns than XLK, it has also exhibited higher volatility. This indicates that MSCI is a riskier investment than XLK. The drawdown figures further support this conclusion, with MSCI experiencing larger maximum drawdowns than XLK.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance: XLK has consistently offered a better risk-adjusted return than MSCI, as evidenced by its higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that XLK has been a more efficient investment, generating higher returns for a given level of risk. The beta values of both MSCI and XLK are greater than 1, indicating that both instruments are more sensitive to market movements than the overall market. However, the consistency of their beta values suggests that their risk profiles are similar.
  • Overall Assessment: MSCI has underperformed XLK in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns. While MSCI's higher volatility may appeal to some investors seeking higher potential returns, its larger drawdowns and lower Sharpe ratio suggest that it is a riskier investment than XLK. Investors seeking a more stable and efficient investment with better risk-adjusted returns may prefer XLK.
Peers Price History(as of 2024-09-12)
Moody's Corp. (MCO)Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. (ICE)
  • Performance Comparison:
    • MSCI has significantly underperformed both MCO and ICE over all the listed periods. This underperformance is particularly pronounced over longer periods, such as the 3-year period, where MSCI has experienced a decline in value while both MCO and ICE have shown significant gains.
    • MSCI's performance has been consistently lower than both MCO and ICE, indicating a lack of competitiveness in terms of stock price appreciation.
  • Risk and Return Analysis:
    • MSCI has provided lower annualized returns than both MCO and ICE over all the listed periods. This suggests that MSCI has not been as successful in generating returns for investors as its peers.
    • MSCI has exhibited higher annualized volatility than both MCO and ICE, indicating that its stock price is more susceptible to fluctuations in the market. This higher volatility comes with a higher risk profile for investors.
    • MSCI has experienced the largest maximum drawdown of the three companies, reaching 43.74% in Q2 2022. This indicates that MSCI's stock price is more vulnerable to significant declines during market downturns.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance:
    • MSCI's Sharpe Ratio has been consistently lower than MCO's, indicating that MCO has offered a better risk-adjusted return over the period.
    • MSCI's Beta value consistently above 1 suggests that it has a higher risk profile than both MCO and ICE. This means that MSCI's stock price is more likely to fluctuate in response to market movements.
  • Overall Assessment:
    • MSCI has consistently underperformed its peers, MCO and ICE, in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns. This underperformance is likely due to MSCI's higher volatility and larger drawdowns, which indicate a higher risk profile for investors.
    • While MSCI's beta values have been trending downwards in recent quarters, suggesting that it is becoming less sensitive to market movements, it still remains higher than both MCO and ICE.
    • Investors seeking a more stable and less risky investment may want to consider MCO or ICE over MSCI. However, investors with a higher risk tolerance and a longer investment horizon may be willing to accept MSCI's higher volatility in the hope of potentially higher returns in the future.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2024-06-30)
Moody's Corp. (MCO)Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. (ICE)

  1. Market Position and Size:

    • MSCI is the smallest company in the peer group, with a market capitalization of 44024.3, significantly smaller than Moody's Corp. (MCO) at 87180.4 and Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. (ICE) at 92517.2.
    • Despite its smaller size, MSCI generates a relatively high level of revenue, EBITDA, and net income compared to its peers, suggesting efficient profit generation.
    • MSCI's smaller size may provide flexibility to adapt to market changes and pursue new growth opportunities.

  2. Profitability and Efficiency:

    • MSCI significantly outperforms its peers and the industry average in profitability metrics like Gross Profit Margin, EBITDA Margin, and Net Profit Margin.
    • This high profitability is likely due to its focus on high-value, specialized data and analytics services for institutional investors.
    • MSCI's efficiency in generating returns is impressive, especially considering its smaller size, indicating effective operations and smart investments.

  3. Financial Health and Stability:

    • MSCI's liquidity metrics are generally in line with peers and the industry average, but could be improved.
    • The company's debt position is relatively healthy, with a Debt / EBITDA ratio below the industry average, indicating capacity for further debt if needed.
    • MSCI's strong profitability and cash flow generation provide a cushion against potential liquidity risks.

  4. Valuation and Market Perception:

    • MSCI's valuation metrics are generally in line with its peers and the industry average, but are relatively high.
    • The company's high profitability and growth prospects justify its premium valuation.
    • The market's positive view of MSCI's future prospects is reflected in its valuation.

  5. Cash Flow and Capital Management:

    • MSCI's cash flow generation is strong, but lower than its peers, likely due to its smaller size.
    • The company's strong profitability and efficient operations suggest potential for increased cash flow generation in the future.
    • MSCI's cash flow generation provides flexibility for growth investments, debt repayment, or shareholder returns.

  6. Growth and Future Prospects:

    • MSCI's growth metrics are generally higher than the peer group average, indicating strong performance.
    • The company's growth has been relatively stable over the past 5 years, with some year-to-year fluctuations.
    • MSCI's 5-year CAGRs are generally higher than its 3-year CAGRs, suggesting accelerating growth.
    • Growth is concentrated in core business areas, but challenges in capital and investment management may require attention.

  7. Potential for Investment:

    • MSCI presents an attractive investment opportunity for investors seeking exposure to the data processing services industry.
    • The company's strong track record of performance, high profitability, and growth prospects are positive factors.
    • MSCI's relatively low valuation suggests potential undervaluation by the market.
    • Investors should consider the risks associated with its smaller size, lower liquidity, and high debt levels.

  8. Key Risks and Considerations:

    • MSCI's smaller size may make it more vulnerable to liquidity risks and limit its cash flow generation compared to peers.
    • The company's high level of debt, while mitigated by strong profitability, is a potential risk factor.
    • Maintaining its competitive advantage will depend on continued innovation and development of new products and services.

  9. Overall Assessment:

    • MSCI is a financially healthy company with strong profitability, efficiency, and growth prospects.
    • The company's competitive position in the data processing services industry is strong, but it faces challenges in managing capital and investments.
    • While its smaller size and high debt levels present risks, MSCI's overall financial performance and future potential make it an attractive investment opportunity.