Thematic evaluation
Back to company overview

Progressive Corp. (PGR)

September 30, 2024

Compared to: The Travelers Cos., Inc. (TRV) | Chubb Ltd. (CB) | Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF)

Our reasoning

Progressive Corp. (PGR) appears undervalued primarily due to its strong financial performance, growth prospects, and conservative capital structure, which are not fully reflected in its current valuation multiples. The company's successful expansion in homeowners insurance and potential efficiency gains from technology investments offer significant upside potential, while its strong market position and dual-channel strategy provide a competitive advantage in a challenging industry.

Key takeaways
  • Progressive Corp. (PGR) is a financially strong company with a strong track record of growth and profitability.
  • PGR's growth opportunities include expanding its presence in the homeowners insurance market, investing in technology, and potentially pursuing acquisitions.
  • PGR faces several risks, including increasing expenses, exposure to catastrophic losses, cybersecurity threats, and competition.
  • PGR's valuation metrics suggest that the company is undervalued by the market.
  • PGR's stock price has outperformed its benchmark and peers over all listed periods, demonstrating a strong track record of performance.
  • PGR's future outlook is positive, with continued revenue growth and improved profitability expected. However, the company faces several risks that could impact its future performance.
  • PGR's investment profile is characterized by strong financial performance, significant growth potential, and a conservative capital structure. However, the company faces several risks that investors should carefully consider.
Undervalued
Ask a question about Progressive Corp. (PGR)
Evaluation summary

  1. Company Overview:

    • Progressive Corp. (PGR) is a leading provider of personal and commercial auto insurance, residential property insurance, and other specialty insurance products in the United States. The company operates through three main business segments: Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and Property. Progressive sells its products through both independent insurance agencies (Agency channel) and directly to consumers (Direct channel).
    • PGR's core products and services include personal auto insurance, commercial auto insurance, homeowners insurance, and other specialty insurance products. The company's revenue is primarily generated from premiums earned from these insurance products.
    • PGR's target market is primarily individuals and small businesses in the United States. The company focuses on providing insurance products that meet the specific needs of its target customers.
    • We will be using the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) as a benchmark for PGR's price performance and comparing PGR's financial performance and valuation to its industry peers Chubb Ltd. (CB) and The Travelers Cos., Inc. (TRV).

  2. Financial Performance:

    • PGR has experienced strong revenue growth in recent years, driven by its core business of personal and commercial auto insurance and its expansion into the homeowners insurance market. The company's revenue has grown at a CAGR of 10.2% over the past three years.
    • PGR's profitability has been declining in recent quarters due to increasing expenses, particularly in the area of advertising spending. The company's net profit margin has declined from 11.77% in Q4 2023 to 8.05% in Q2 2024.
    • PGR's return on average assets (ROA), return on average total equity (ROE), return on average total capital (ROTC), and return on average invested capital (ROIC) are all significantly higher than the industry average, indicating that the company is effectively utilizing its assets and capital to generate profits.
    • Compared to its peers, PGR has consistently outperformed both CB and TRV in terms of revenue growth and profitability. However, PGR's profitability has been declining at a faster rate than its peers, which could be a concern for investors.

  3. Operational Efficiency:

    • PGR's balance sheet has shown a strong trend of increasing assets, particularly in the form of investments and premium balance receivables. This indicates a healthy growth strategy and a strong financial position.
    • PGR's working capital management appears to be efficient, with a stable current ratio and quick ratio. However, the decreasing trend in cash only could be a concern.
    • PGR's cash flow is strong, with a healthy level of free cash flow generation. This provides the company with flexibility to pursue growth opportunities and return capital to shareholders.
    • PGR's asset quality appears to be strong, with a low level of goodwill and intangibles. This indicates a focus on tangible assets and a conservative approach to acquisitions.
    • PGR's free cash flow margin has been relatively stable in recent quarters, indicating a consistent ability to generate cash flow from operations.
    • PGR's capital expenditures have been increasing in recent quarters, indicating a focus on organic growth and investment in its business.
    • PGR has a history of paying dividends and repurchasing shares, which is sustainable given its strong cash flow generation.
    • Compared to its peers, PGR has a higher level of operational efficiency, as evidenced by its strong cash flow generation and asset utilization. However, PGR's increasing capital expenditures could be a concern for investors if it leads to a decline in free cash flow.
    • PGR's liquidity position is healthy, with a current ratio and quick ratio that are above the industry average. However, the decreasing trend in cash only could be a concern.
    • PGR's debt-to-equity ratio is significantly below the industry average, indicating a conservative capital structure with a low level of debt.

  4. Growth Opportunities:

    • PGR is expanding its presence in the homeowners insurance market, both through the direct and independent agent channels. This is a significant growth opportunity for the company, as the homeowners insurance market is expected to grow in the coming years.
    • PGR is also investing in technology, data analytics, and personalization to enhance the customer experience and drive efficiency in its direct-to-consumer business. This is a key strategic focus area for the company, as it seeks to gain market share in the increasingly competitive direct-to-consumer insurance market.
    • PGR has a history of successful acquisitions, which could be a potential growth strategy for the company in the future. However, the company has not announced any major acquisitions in recent years.
    • PGR's geographic expansion plans are focused on expanding its presence in less catastrophe-prone regions. This is a strategic move to mitigate the risk of catastrophic losses, which have been a significant challenge for the company in recent years.
    • PGR's management team has a strong track record of executing on its strategic plans. This is a positive sign for investors, as it indicates that the company is capable of achieving its growth objectives.

  5. Risks and Threats:

    • PGR's profitability is declining due to increasing expenses, particularly in the area of advertising spending. This is a significant risk for the company, as it could lead to a decline in shareholder value.
    • PGR's exposure to severe weather events and catastrophic losses remains a significant risk. This is a major challenge for the insurance industry as a whole, and PGR is particularly vulnerable due to its large presence in catastrophe-prone regions.
    • PGR's reliance on third-party systems and potential for cybersecurity breaches or other technology disruptions is a risk. This is a growing concern for all businesses, and PGR is particularly vulnerable due to its reliance on technology to operate its business.
    • PGR's highly competitive insurance markets and potential for industry consolidation or disruptive new entrants is a risk. This is a constant challenge for the insurance industry, and PGR must continue to innovate and adapt to remain competitive.
    • PGR's ongoing litigation related to claims handling and business practices represents a persistent legal and reputational risk. This is a significant risk for the company, as it could lead to negative publicity and financial losses.

  6. Valuation Analysis:

    • PGR's valuation metrics, such as its P/E ratio and EV/EBITDA ratio, are currently below the industry average. This suggests that the company is undervalued by the market.
    • Compared to its peers, PGR is trading at a discount to its peers, which could be an attractive entry point for investors.
    • Potential catalysts for PGR's stock price include continued revenue growth, improved profitability, and a reduction in its exposure to catastrophic losses.

  7. Price Performance:

    • PGR's stock price has outperformed the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over all listed periods, demonstrating a strong track record of performance. PGR's outperformance has been particularly significant over the past three years, where it has outpaced XLF by 158.56%.
    • PGR's performance has been relatively consistent, with the exception of a slight underperformance in the past week. This suggests that PGR has been able to maintain its strong performance over time.
    • Compared to its peers, PGR has consistently outperformed both CB and TRV over all the periods analyzed, demonstrating a strong track record of growth. This outperformance is particularly notable in the longer-term periods, indicating a sustainable growth strategy.

  8. Future Outlook:

    • PGR's management team has expressed confidence in the company's ability to continue growing profitably, citing the strength of its brand, segmentation, and customer experience.
    • Analyst estimates for PGR's future earnings growth are generally positive, with a consensus expectation of continued revenue growth and improved profitability.
    • Potential headwinds for PGR's future performance include continued increases in expenses, exposure to catastrophic losses, and regulatory changes.

  9. Summary:

    • PGR is a financially strong company with a strong track record of growth and profitability. The company has a conservative capital structure and a healthy level of free cash flow generation.
    • PGR's growth opportunities include expanding its presence in the homeowners insurance market, investing in technology, and potentially pursuing acquisitions.
    • PGR faces several risks, including increasing expenses, exposure to catastrophic losses, cybersecurity threats, and competition.
    • PGR's valuation metrics suggest that the company is undervalued by the market.
    • PGR's stock price has outperformed its benchmark and peers over all listed periods, demonstrating a strong track record of performance.
    • PGR's future outlook is positive, with continued revenue growth and improved profitability expected. However, the company faces several risks that could impact its future performance.
    • PGR's investment profile is characterized by strong financial performance, significant growth potential, and a conservative capital structure. However, the company faces several risks that investors should carefully consider.
Peer fundamentals 
Fundamentals
Insights
  • Progressive is experiencing strong revenue growth, driven by its core business of personal and commercial auto insurance and its expansion into the homeowners insurance market.
  • The company's profitability is declining due to increasing expenses, particularly in the area of advertising spending.
  • The company's liquidity position is healthy, but the decreasing trend in cash only could be a concern.
  • The company's long-term solvency is strong, with a conservative capital structure and a low level of debt.
  • The company's asset utilization efficiency is high, as evidenced by the strong return on average assets, return on average total equity, return on average total capital, and return on average invested capital.
  • The company's cash flow is strong, with a healthy level of free cash flow generation.
  • The company's investment strategy appears to be focused on organic growth, as evidenced by the increasing trend in capital expenditures.
  • The company's future outlook is positive, with strong revenue growth expected to continue. However, profitability is likely to remain under pressure due to increasing expenses.
Analysis
  • Revenue - The company is experiencing strong revenue growth, driven by its core business of personal and commercial auto insurance. - This growth is being fueled by the company's focus on expanding its presence in the homeowners insurance market and its significant investments in technology, data analytics, and usage-based insurance products like Snapshot. - The company's dual-channel strategy, with a strong presence in both the independent agent and direct-to-consumer channels, is a key competitive advantage.
    • Profitability
      • The company's profitability is declining due to increasing expenses, particularly in the area of advertising spending.
      • The company's net profit margin is below the industry average, indicating that the company is less profitable than its peers.
      • However, the company's return on average assets, return on average total equity, return on average total capital, and return on average invested capital are all significantly higher than the industry average, indicating that the company is effectively utilizing its assets and capital to generate profits.
    • Liquidity
      • The company's liquidity position appears to be healthy, with a current ratio of 0.74, which is slightly below the industry average.
      • However, the decreasing trend in cash only could be a concern.
    • Solvency
      • The company's long-term solvency appears to be strong, with a low debt-to-equity ratio of 29.52, which is significantly below the industry average.
      • This indicates that the company has a conservative capital structure with a low level of debt.
    • Operational Efficiency
      • The company's asset utilization efficiency is high, as evidenced by the strong return on average assets, return on average total equity, return on average total capital, and return on average invested capital.
      • This indicates that the company is effectively utilizing its assets and capital to generate profits.
    • Cash Flow Analysis
      • The company's cash flow is strong, with a healthy level of free cash flow generation.
      • This provides the company with flexibility to pursue growth opportunities and return capital to shareholders.
      • The company's investment strategy appears to be focused on organic growth, as evidenced by the increasing trend in capital expenditures.
    • Risk Factors
      • The company's profitability is declining due to increasing expenses, particularly in the area of advertising spending.
      • The company's exposure to severe weather events and catastrophic losses remains a significant risk.
      • The company's reliance on third-party systems and potential for cybersecurity breaches or other technology disruptions is a risk.
      • The company's highly competitive insurance markets and potential for industry consolidation or disruptive new entrants is a risk.
      • The company's ongoing litigation related to claims handling and business practices represents a persistent legal and reputational risk.
    • Future Outlook
      • The company is expected to continue to experience strong revenue growth, driven by its core business of personal and commercial auto insurance and its expansion into the homeowners insurance market.
      • However, profitability is likely to remain under pressure due to increasing expenses.
      • The company's strong financial position provides flexibility to pursue growth opportunities and return capital to shareholders.
Most recent earnings report
Financial statements 
All public filings
Comparative Analysis
Benchmarks (as of 2024-09-27)
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF)
  • Performance Comparison:
    • Progressive Corp. (PGR) has consistently outperformed the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) over all listed periods, demonstrating a strong track record of performance. PGR's outperformance has been particularly significant over the past three years, where it has outpaced XLF by 158.56%.
    • PGR's performance has been relatively consistent, with the exception of a slight underperformance in the past week. This suggests that PGR has been able to maintain its strong performance over time.
  • Risk and Return Analysis:
    • PGR has provided higher annualized returns than XLF over all listed periods, indicating that it has generated greater returns for investors. However, PGR's annualized volatility has also been higher than XLF's, suggesting that PGR is a more volatile investment.
    • PGR's maximum drawdown of 22.91% is slightly lower than XLF's maximum drawdown of 25.81%, indicating that PGR has experienced slightly smaller peak-to-trough declines. However, both instruments have experienced frequent drawdowns, suggesting that both are subject to market fluctuations.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance:
    • PGR's Sharpe Ratio has generally been lower than XLF's, indicating that XLF has offered a better risk-adjusted return over the period. This suggests that XLF has been able to generate higher returns for investors while taking on less risk.
    • PGR's beta has consistently been below 1, indicating that it is less volatile than the overall market. This suggests that PGR is less sensitive to market movements than XLF, which has a beta closer to 1.
  • Overall Assessment:
    • PGR has demonstrated strong performance, consistently outperforming XLF over all listed periods. However, PGR's higher volatility and lower Sharpe Ratio suggest that it is a riskier investment than XLF. PGR's lower beta indicates a lower risk profile, suggesting that it is less sensitive to market fluctuations.
    • Investors seeking higher returns may be willing to accept PGR's higher volatility. However, investors seeking a more stable investment with a better risk-adjusted return may prefer XLF.
Peers Price History(as of 2024-09-27)
The Travelers Cos., Inc. (TRV)Chubb Ltd. (CB)
  • Performance Comparison:
    • PGR has consistently outperformed both CB and TRV over all the periods analyzed, demonstrating a strong track record of growth. This outperformance is particularly notable in the longer-term periods, indicating a sustainable growth strategy.
  • Risk and Return Analysis:
    • PGR has provided higher annualized returns than both CB and TRV across all periods, suggesting a more aggressive growth strategy. However, this comes with a higher level of volatility.
    • PGR has exhibited higher annualized volatility than both CB and TRV, indicating a higher risk profile. This is consistent with its higher returns, as higher risk often comes with the potential for higher rewards.
    • PGR has experienced the largest maximum drawdown of 22.91% on 07/13/2023, compared to 19.26% for CB on 06/28/2023 and 18.9% for TRV on 09/26/2022. This suggests that PGR is more susceptible to market downturns and may experience larger losses during periods of market volatility.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance:
    • CB consistently shows a higher Sharpe ratio than PGR and TRV across most periods, indicating that it has better risk-adjusted returns. This suggests that CB is able to generate higher returns for a given level of risk compared to PGR.
    • PGR's beta, consistently below 1, indicates that it is less sensitive to market movements than its peers, making it a potentially less risky investment. However, its higher volatility and larger drawdowns suggest that it may still be subject to significant risk.
  • Overall Assessment:
    • PGR has demonstrated strong performance and growth potential, consistently outperforming its peers. However, it comes with a higher risk profile, as evidenced by its higher volatility and larger drawdowns.
    • CB, while offering lower returns than PGR, has a better risk-adjusted performance, as indicated by its higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that CB may be a more suitable investment for investors seeking a more balanced approach to risk and return.
    • TRV has exhibited moderate performance and risk characteristics, falling between PGR and CB in terms of both returns and volatility.
    • Investors should carefully consider their risk tolerance and investment goals when evaluating these companies. PGR may be attractive for investors seeking high growth potential, while CB may be more suitable for those seeking a more balanced approach to risk and return.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2024-06-30)
The Travelers Cos., Inc. (TRV)Chubb Ltd. (CB)

  1. Market Position and Size:

    • PGR is the largest company in the peer group, with a market cap significantly larger than its peers, Chubb Ltd. (CB) and The Travelers Cos., Inc. (TRV).
    • PGR's market cap of 139,260.0 is 28,570.0 greater than CB's market cap of 110,690.0 and 89,354.5 greater than TRV's market cap of 49,905.5.
    • PGR's size and market value are directly related to its revenue generation capabilities, as its revenue of 18,127.0 is 4,252.0 greater than CB's revenue of 13,875.0 and 6,844.0 greater than TRV's revenue of 11,283.0.
    • PGR's size and market value are not solely driven by profitability, but also by other factors such as revenue growth and market share, as its net income of 1,458.7 is 771.3 less than CB's net income of 2,230.0, but 924.7 greater than TRV's net income of 534.0.

  2. Profitability and Efficiency:

    • PGR's Gross Profit Margin, EBITDA Margin, and Net Profit Margin are all lower than the industry average.
    • PGR's Net Profit Margin of 8.05% is 3.46% lower than the industry average of 11.51%.
    • PGR's profitability is relatively low considering its size and revenue.
    • PGR is underperforming in profitability metrics compared to both peers and industry standards.
    • PGR's Return on Average Assets, Return on Average Total Equity, Return on Average Total Capital, and Return On Average Invested Capital are all significantly higher than the peer and industry averages.
    • PGR's Return on Average Assets of 8.12% is 5.63% higher than the industry average of 2.49%.
    • PGR's efficiency in generating returns is high relative to its size and market position.

  3. Financial Health and Stability:

    • PGR's Current Ratio, Quick Ratio, Total Debt to Total Equity Ratio, and Debt / EBITDA are all lower than the peer and industry averages.
    • PGR's Current Ratio of 0.74 is 0.77 lower than the industry average of 1.51%.
    • PGR's liquidity and debt position are relatively low in relation to its market cap and peer group.
    • PGR's balance sheet composition is significantly different from its peers, considering relative company sizes.
    • PGR has a higher proportion of total liabilities compared to its peers.
    • PGR's Total Liabilities of 69,380.4 is 81,202.6 less than CB's Total Liabilities of 150,583.0.
    • PGR's balance sheet structure is significantly different from peers and industry norms.

  4. Valuation and Market Perception:

    • PGR's Enterprise Value To Sales, Enterprise Value To EBITDA, Price To Earnings, Price to Book Ratio, and Price To Sales Ratio are all higher than the peer and industry averages.
    • PGR's Price To Earnings ratio of 20.34 is 110.48 lower than the industry average of 130.82.
    • PGR's valuation is high in the context of its market cap, peer group, and industry standards.

  5. Cash Flow and Capital Management:

    • PGR's Net Operating Cash Flow, Total Capital Expenditure, and Free Cash Flow are all lower than the peer averages, considering market caps.
    • PGR's Free Cash Flow of 3,197.9 is 1,242.1 less than CB's Free Cash Flow of 4,440.0.
    • PGR's cash flow generation strength is relatively low compared to its size, peers, and industry norms.

  6. Growth and Future Prospects:

    • PGR shows consistently higher growth in sales/revenue, net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, free cash flow margin, total assets, and book value per share compared to the peer group average.
    • PGR's 5-year CAGR for sales/revenue is 13.97%, which is 3.42% higher than the peer group average of 10.55%.
    • PGR's year-over-year growth rates for net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, free cash flow margin, total assets, and book value per share have experienced significant fluctuations over the past 5 years.
    • PGR's 5-year CAGR for sales/revenue, net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, free cash flow margin, total assets, and book value per share are all higher than the peer group average.
    • PGR's growth in sales/revenue, net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, free cash flow margin, total assets, and book value per share has been consistently increasing over the past 5 years.
    • PGR's most recent year-over-year growth rates for sales/revenue, net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, free cash flow margin, total assets, and book value per share are all higher than its 5-year CAGRs.
    • PGR's growth is balanced across different metrics.

  7. Potential for Investment:

    • PGR presents an interesting investment opportunity with strong growth potential and high efficiency, but investors should consider its lower profitability and cash flow generation.
    • PGR's strong revenue growth, high Return on Average Assets, and consistent growth in key metrics suggest a healthy and sustainable growth trajectory.
    • PGR's lower Net Profit Margin and Free Cash Flow compared to peers may be a concern for investors seeking high profitability and cash flow generation.
    • PGR's higher leverage also presents a risk to its financial stability.

  8. Key Risks and Considerations:

    • PGR's lower profitability and cash flow generation compared to peers may indicate potential inefficiencies in operations or higher costs.
    • PGR's higher leverage presents a risk to its financial stability, as it may be more vulnerable to financial distress if its business operations decline.

  9. Overall Assessment:

    • PGR is a large and dominant player in the multi-line insurance industry with strong growth potential and high efficiency.
    • However, PGR faces challenges in profitability and cash flow generation, which may be a concern for investors seeking high returns.
    • PGR's higher leverage also presents a risk to its financial stability.
    • Overall, PGR is a financially healthy company with a strong market position, but investors should carefully consider its profitability, cash flow generation, and leverage before making an investment decision.