Thematic evaluation
Back to company overview

Tesla, Inc. (TSLA)

October 17, 2024

Compared to: General Motors Co. (GM) | Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER) | Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY)

Our reasoning

Tesla's current valuation appears moderately overvalued based on its high P/E and EV/EBITDA multiples compared to peers and historical averages, declining profitability, and increasing competition in the EV market. While the company has strong growth prospects and a leading market position, these factors are already priced in, and the current valuation doesn't adequately account for the significant risks and challenges Tesla faces.

Key takeaways
  • Tesla's revenue growth is strong, but it is facing increasing competition in both its automotive and energy storage businesses.
  • The company's profitability is under pressure due to rising costs and investments in growth.
  • Tesla's liquidity position appears strong, but the company's increasing reliance on debt financing could potentially strain its liquidity in the future.
  • The company's long-term solvency appears healthy, but the company's increasing debt levels could pose a risk to its financial stability, especially if interest rates rise or economic conditions deteriorate.
  • Tesla's cash flow from operations has been declining, which could be attributed to factors such as increased competition, rising costs, and macroeconomic headwinds.
  • The company's capital expenditures have been increasing at a faster rate than depreciation, indicating a significant investment in growth.
  • The company's free cash flow is expected to remain positive, which could provide it with the financial flexibility to repay debt, invest in growth opportunities, and potentially return value to shareholders.
  • The company's announced strategic initiatives, such as the development of Optimus and the expansion of its Supercharger network, are likely to have a significant impact on its future cash flows and earnings.
Overvalued
Ask a question about Tesla, Inc. (TSLA)
Evaluation summary

  1. Company Overview:

    • Tesla, Inc. (TSLA) is a leading electric vehicle (EV) and clean energy company, operating in two main segments: Automotive and Energy Generation and Storage. The company designs, develops, manufactures, sells, and leases high-performance fully electric vehicles, solar energy generation systems, and energy storage products.
    • Tesla's key products include the Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X, Cybertruck, and energy storage products like Powerwall and Megapack. The company sells its vehicles directly to customers through an international network of company-owned stores and galleries.
    • Tesla's target market is comprised of environmentally conscious consumers seeking high-performance, technologically advanced vehicles and sustainable energy solutions. The company faces competition from established automakers like General Motors (GM) and new entrants in the EV and energy storage markets, such as Uber Technologies (UBER).
    • For comparative analysis, we will be using the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY) as a benchmark and General Motors (GM) and Uber Technologies (UBER) as industry peers.

  2. Financial Performance:

    • Tesla's revenue has been growing steadily, driven by strong demand for its electric vehicles and energy storage products. The company's revenue growth is being driven by the increasing demand for electric vehicles and energy storage products, as well as the company's expansion into new markets.
    • Tesla's profitability has been declining, reflecting the pressure on margins and the impact of non-recurring items. The company's profitability is under pressure due to rising costs and investments in growth.
    • Tesla's return on assets (ROA), return on equity (ROE), and return on invested capital (ROIC) have been improving, indicating that the company is becoming more efficient in utilizing its assets to generate profits. However, these metrics are still below the industry average, suggesting that Tesla may be facing challenges in achieving profitability levels comparable to its peers.
    • Compared to its peers, Tesla's revenue growth has been stronger, but its profitability has been lower. This suggests that Tesla may be sacrificing profitability for growth, which could be a concern for investors seeking long-term value creation.

  3. Operational Efficiency:

    • Tesla's working capital management has been improving, with a decreasing reliance on short-term debt and a more efficient use of accounts receivable. However, the company's high inventory levels could indicate potential inefficiencies in its supply chain or production processes.
    • Tesla's cash flow from operations has been declining, which could be attributed to factors such as increased competition, rising costs, and macroeconomic headwinds. The company's capital expenditures have been increasing at a faster rate than depreciation, indicating a significant investment in growth.
    • Tesla's free cash flow has been positive, but it has been declining in recent quarters. This could be a concern for investors seeking a company with strong cash flow generation capabilities.
    • Tesla's asset quality appears to be improving, as evidenced by the increasing return on assets and return on equity. However, the company's high capital expenditures could potentially limit its ability to further improve efficiency.
    • Tesla's short-term liquidity position appears strong, with a significant amount of cash and short-term investments. However, the company's increasing reliance on debt financing could potentially strain its liquidity in the future.
    • Tesla's long-term solvency appears healthy, with a strong equity base and a growing asset base. However, the company's increasing debt levels could pose a risk to its financial stability, especially if interest rates rise or economic conditions deteriorate.
    • Compared to its peers, Tesla's operational efficiency is mixed. While the company has shown improvements in working capital management and asset utilization, its declining cash flow from operations and increasing capital expenditures raise concerns about its ability to sustain its growth trajectory.

  4. Growth Opportunities:

    • Tesla is aggressively expanding its manufacturing capacity and product lineup, including new models like the Cybertruck, while also investing heavily in autonomous driving and AI technologies. The company is also expanding its global presence, with new Gigafactories in various regions.
    • Tesla's R&D pipeline is robust, with a focus on developing advanced battery technologies, autonomous driving capabilities, and new vehicle models. The company is also investing in the development of Optimus, a humanoid robot that could potentially revolutionize various industries.
    • Tesla's strategic focus areas include expanding its manufacturing capacity, developing autonomous driving technology, and scaling its energy storage business. The company is also exploring opportunities in new markets, such as the commercial trucking industry.
    • Tesla's management has a history of making bold predictions and setting ambitious goals. While the company has achieved some of its targets, it has also faced challenges in meeting others. This suggests that investors should be cautious about relying solely on management's pronouncements when assessing Tesla's future prospects.

  5. Risks and Threats:

    • Tesla faces significant risks, including competition from established automakers and new EV startups, supply chain disruptions, regulatory changes, cybersecurity threats, and macroeconomic headwinds.
    • The company's reliance on single-source suppliers and its exposure to fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates could also pose challenges.
    • Tesla's high capital expenditures and its increasing debt levels could strain its financial flexibility and potentially limit its ability to invest in future growth opportunities.
    • Tesla's legal and regulatory environment is complex, with ongoing litigation, government investigations, and evolving rules around electric vehicles and self-driving technology.
    • Tesla's reliance on regulatory credits for a significant portion of its revenue could be a concern, as these credits are subject to changes in government policies and the actions of other automakers.

  6. Valuation Analysis:

    • Tesla's valuation metrics, such as its price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio and enterprise value-to-EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) ratio, are significantly higher than those of its peers and the broader market. This suggests that investors are placing a premium on Tesla's growth potential and its leadership position in the EV market.
    • However, Tesla's high valuation is also a source of risk, as it leaves the company vulnerable to a decline in investor sentiment or a slowdown in its growth trajectory.
    • Potential catalysts for Tesla's stock price include the successful launch of new products, the expansion of its manufacturing capacity, and the development of its autonomous driving technology.

  7. Price Performance:

    • Tesla's stock price has been volatile, with periods of significant gains and losses. The company's stock price has underperformed the broader market and its peers over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months.
    • Tesla's high beta indicates that it is a riskier investment than the broader market and its peers. This suggests that Tesla's stock price is likely to fluctuate more than its peers during periods of market volatility.

  8. Future Outlook:

    • Tesla's management has expressed confidence in the company's ability to achieve unsupervised full self-driving capability and scale Optimus production, though they acknowledged past overly optimistic predictions.
    • The company is investing heavily in AI infrastructure, including a new 50,000 GPU cluster, to support its autonomous driving and Optimus humanoid robot initiatives, which the company believes will be the key long-term value drivers.
    • Tesla is facing increased competition in the EV market, leading to discounting, but the management team remains confident in the company's ability to maintain its competitive edge through its focus on autonomy and manufacturing efficiency.
    • Analyst estimates for Tesla's future performance are mixed, with some analysts expecting continued strong growth and others expressing concerns about the company's valuation and its ability to maintain its market leadership position.

  9. Summary:

    • Tesla is a leading EV and clean energy company with strong revenue growth and a robust R&D pipeline. However, the company faces significant challenges, including declining profitability, increasing competition, and a complex legal and regulatory environment.
    • Tesla's high valuation and its volatile stock price make it a risky investment. However, the company's potential for future growth and its leadership position in the EV market could make it an attractive investment for investors with a high risk tolerance.
    • Key factors to monitor for Tesla's future performance include its ability to maintain its revenue growth, improve its profitability, manage its debt levels, and execute its strategic initiatives successfully.
    • Overall, Tesla is a company with both significant potential and significant risks. Investors should carefully consider all of these factors before making any investment decisions.
Peer fundamentals 
Fundamentals
Insights
  • Tesla's revenue growth is strong, but it is facing increasing competition in both its automotive and energy storage businesses.
  • The company's profitability is under pressure due to rising costs and investments in growth.
  • Tesla's liquidity position appears strong, with a significant amount of cash and short-term investments. However, the company's increasing reliance on debt financing could potentially strain its liquidity in the future.
  • The company's long-term solvency appears healthy, with a strong equity base and a growing asset base. However, the company's increasing debt levels could pose a risk to its financial stability, especially if interest rates rise or economic conditions deteriorate.
  • Tesla's cash flow from operations has been declining, which could be attributed to factors such as increased competition, rising costs, and macroeconomic headwinds.
  • The company's capital expenditures have been increasing at a faster rate than depreciation, indicating a significant investment in growth.
  • The company's free cash flow is expected to remain positive, which could provide it with the financial flexibility to repay debt, invest in growth opportunities, and potentially return value to shareholders.
  • The company's announced strategic initiatives, such as the development of Optimus and the expansion of its Supercharger network, are likely to have a significant impact on its future cash flows and earnings.
Analysis
  • Revenue - Tesla's revenue has been growing steadily, driven by strong demand for its electric vehicles and energy storage products. - The company's revenue growth is being driven by the increasing demand for electric vehicles and energy storage products, as well as the company's expansion into new markets. - The company's revenue growth is expected to continue, driven by the increasing demand for electric vehicles and energy storage products.
    • Profitability
      • Tesla's profitability has been declining, reflecting the pressure on margins and the impact of non-recurring items.
      • The company's profitability is under pressure due to rising costs and investments in growth.
      • The company's profitability is expected to improve as it scales its operations and achieves greater efficiencies.
    • Liquidity
      • Tesla's liquidity position appears strong, with a significant amount of cash and short-term investments.
      • The company's increasing reliance on debt financing could potentially strain its liquidity in the future.
      • The company's short-term liquidity position appears strong, with a significant amount of cash and short-term investments.
    • Solvency
      • Tesla's long-term solvency appears healthy, with a strong equity base and a growing asset base.
      • The company's increasing debt levels could pose a risk to its financial stability, especially if interest rates rise or economic conditions deteriorate.
      • The company's long-term solvency appears healthy, with a strong equity base and a growing asset base.
    • Operational Efficiency
      • Tesla's asset utilization efficiency appears to be improving, as evidenced by the increasing return on assets and return on equity.
      • The company's high capital expenditures could potentially limit its ability to further improve efficiency.
      • The company's free cash flow margin has been increasing, indicating that it is generating more free cash flow relative to its sales.
    • Cash Flow Analysis
      • Tesla's cash flow from operations has been declining, which could be attributed to factors such as increased competition, rising costs, and macroeconomic headwinds.
      • The company's capital expenditures have been increasing at a faster rate than depreciation, indicating a significant investment in growth.
      • The company's free cash flow is expected to remain positive, which could provide it with the financial flexibility to repay debt, invest in growth opportunities, and potentially return value to shareholders.
    • Risk Factors
      • The company's increasing reliance on debt financing could potentially strain its liquidity in the future.
      • The company's increasing debt levels could pose a risk to its financial stability, especially if interest rates rise or economic conditions deteriorate.
      • The company's high capital expenditures could potentially limit its ability to further improve efficiency.
      • The company's net income growth has been outpaced by its operating cash flow growth, suggesting that its earnings may not be fully reflective of its underlying cash flow performance.
      • The company's cash flow to net income ratio has been fluctuating, indicating potential volatility in its earnings quality.
      • The company's tax rate has been volatile, which could be a cause for concern.
    • Future Outlook
      • Tesla's balance sheet is likely to continue to grow in the coming quarters, driven by its expansion plans and investments in new technologies.
      • The company's financial flexibility will be impacted by its ability to manage its debt levels and generate sufficient cash flow to cover its capital expenditures.
      • The company's profitability is expected to improve as it scales its operations and achieves greater efficiencies.
      • The company's revenue growth is expected to continue, driven by the increasing demand for electric vehicles and energy storage products.
      • The company's announced strategic initiatives, such as the development of Optimus and the expansion of its Supercharger network, are likely to have a significant impact on its future cash flows and earnings.
Most recent earnings report
Financial statements 
All public filings
Comparative Analysis
Benchmarks (as of 2024-10-11)
Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY)
  • Performance Comparison:
    • TSLA has underperformed XLY over most of the historical periods analyzed, particularly over the past year and two years. This suggests that TSLA has been more susceptible to market downturns than the broader Consumer Discretionary sector. However, TSLA has outperformed XLY over the past six months, indicating a potential shift in investor sentiment.
  • Risk and Return Analysis:
    • TSLA has provided lower annualized returns than XLY over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA has not been as profitable as the broader Consumer Discretionary sector.
    • TSLA has been significantly more volatile than XLY, as evidenced by its higher annualized volatility. This indicates that TSLA's price movements have been more erratic and unpredictable than XLY's.
    • TSLA has experienced significantly larger maximum drawdowns than XLY. This indicates that TSLA is significantly more susceptible to large price declines than XLY.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance:
    • XLY has consistently offered a better risk-adjusted return than TSLA, as indicated by its higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that XLY has been a more efficient investment than TSLA, providing higher returns for a given level of risk.
    • TSLA's higher beta indicates that it is a riskier investment than XLY. This suggests that TSLA's price is likely to fluctuate more than XLY's during periods of market volatility.
  • Overall Assessment:
    • TSLA has underperformed XLY in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA has been a less profitable and riskier investment than the broader Consumer Discretionary sector. However, TSLA's recent outperformance over the past six months and its decreasing volatility in recent quarters may indicate a potential shift in investor sentiment and a more stable future performance. Investors should carefully consider TSLA's high volatility and susceptibility to large drawdowns before making any investment decisions.
Peers Price History(as of 2024-10-11)
General Motors Co. (GM)Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER)
  • Performance Comparison:
    • TSLA has consistently underperformed both GM and UBER over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months. This underperformance is particularly pronounced in the longer timeframes, such as the one-year, two-year, and three-year periods.
    • TSLA's performance has been inconsistent relative to the peer companies, with periods of outperformance and underperformance.
  • Risk and Return Analysis:
    • TSLA has provided lower annualized returns than both GM and UBER over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA's growth potential may be lower than its peers.
    • TSLA has been significantly more volatile than both GM and UBER, as evidenced by its higher annualized volatility. This indicates that TSLA's stock price is more susceptible to fluctuations and market swings.
    • TSLA has experienced larger maximum drawdowns than both GM and UBER. This suggests that TSLA's stock price is more vulnerable to significant declines and carries a higher risk profile.
  • Risk-Adjusted Performance:
    • TSLA's Sharpe Ratio has been consistently lower than GM's and UBER's, indicating that TSLA has not offered a better risk-adjusted return. This suggests that TSLA's returns have not adequately compensated for its higher risk.
    • TSLA's beta value has been consistently higher than GM's and UBER's, indicating that it is more sensitive to market movements. This suggests that TSLA's stock price is more likely to fluctuate in line with broader market trends, potentially amplifying both gains and losses.
  • Overall Assessment:
    • TSLA has consistently underperformed both GM and UBER over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months. This underperformance is particularly pronounced in the longer timeframes, such as the one-year, two-year, and three-year periods.
    • TSLA's higher volatility and larger drawdowns suggest that it carries a higher risk profile than its peers.
    • TSLA's lower Sharpe Ratio indicates that its returns have not adequately compensated for its higher risk.
    • TSLA's higher beta suggests that it is more sensitive to market movements, potentially amplifying both gains and losses.
    • Overall, TSLA's performance, risk, and valuation metrics suggest that it may be a riskier investment than its peers. Investors should carefully consider these factors before making any investment decisions.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2024-06-30)
General Motors Co. (GM)Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER)
  1. Market Position and Size:
    • TSLA holds a dominant market position within its peer group, with a market capitalization significantly larger than both GM and UBER. This dominance is further emphasized by its relatively smaller revenue and profitability compared to GM, suggesting that the market is placing a high value on TSLA's future potential and its position as a leader in the electric vehicle market.
  2. Profitability and Efficiency:
    • TSLA's profitability metrics are mixed compared to its peers and industry averages. While its operating efficiency is relatively strong, its cost structure and expenses are relatively high, resulting in lower profitability margins compared to its peers. However, TSLA's high ROA, ROE, and ROIC indicate that it is effectively utilizing its assets, shareholders' equity, and invested capital to generate profits.
  3. Financial Health and Stability:
    • TSLA's liquidity position is relatively strong, but its debt position is relatively high compared to its peers and industry averages. While its debt burden is manageable, its high debt level could increase its financial risk.
  4. Valuation and Market Perception:
    • TSLA's valuation metrics are significantly higher than its peers and industry averages, reflecting the market's high expectations for its future growth and profitability. This premium valuation suggests that investors are optimistic about TSLA's long-term prospects and its ability to maintain its market leadership in the electric vehicle sector.
  5. Cash Flow and Capital Management:
    • TSLA's cash flow generation strength is relatively strong compared to its size and peers. Its positive free cash flow indicates that TSLA is generating sufficient cash to fund its operations and investments, but its lower capital expenditure compared to its peers suggests a more conservative approach to capital allocation.
  6. Growth and Future Prospect:
    • TSLA's growth trends are mixed compared to its peers and industry averages. While it shows consistently higher growth in sales/revenue, EBITDA, net income, and basic earnings per share compared to the peer group average, its growth rates have been volatile, with significant year-to-year fluctuations. Additionally, its profitability and cash flow generation have been decelerating in recent years, which could be a potential red flag.
  7. Potential for Investment:
    • TSLA's investment attractiveness is a complex issue, with both potential advantages and disadvantages. Its strong growth potential, dominant market position, and high valuation suggest a compelling investment opportunity. However, its volatile growth rates, declining profitability and cash flow generation, and high debt level raise concerns about the sustainability of its growth and its financial risk profile.
  8. Key Risks and Considerations:
    • Investors should be aware of the following key risks and considerations:
      • Volatile Growth Rates: TSLA's growth has been inconsistent, and its future growth may be subject to external factors or changes in its business strategy.
      • Declining Profitability and Cash Flow Generation: TSLA's profitability and cash flow generation have been decelerating in recent years, which could impact its ability to fund future growth and investments.
      • High Debt Level: TSLA's high debt level could increase its financial risk and limit its flexibility in responding to market changes.
      • Competition: TSLA faces increasing competition from both established and emerging players in the electric vehicle market, which could impact its market share and profitability.
  9. Overall Assessment:
    • TSLA's overall financial position, performance, and outlook are characterized by a mix of strengths and weaknesses. While its strong growth and efficiency in generating returns are positive indicators, its volatile growth, declining profitability, and high debt level require careful monitoring and consideration. Its ability to maintain its market leadership and profitability will depend on its ability to innovate, expand its production capacity, and manage its costs effectively.